By Dennis Behreandt - April 16, 2007
On September 26, 2006, the Economic Policy Institute (EPI) unleashed a broadside against the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in the form of a briefing paper by EPI economist Robert E. Scott, Professor Carlos Salas of Mexico’s El Colegio de Tlaxcala, and Bruce Campbell of the Canadian Center for Policy Alternatives. In the opinion of Scott, Salas, and Campbell, NAFTA has been a tragedy for all three nations.
Scott, writing of NAFTA-related problems in the United States, noted: “In the United States workforce, NAFTA has contributed to the reduction of employment in high-wage, traded-goods industries, the growing inequality in wages, and the steadily declining demand for workers without a college education.” According to Scott, those who have lost high-wage jobs have had to take substantial pay cuts to get jobs in the growing service-sector economy. The employment trend has resulted in a much lower standard of living for many Americans. “Growing trade deficits with Mexico and Canada have pushed more than 1 million workers out of higher-wage jobs and into lower-wage positions in non-trade related industries,” Scott notes. “Thus, the displacement of 1 million jobs from traded to non-traded goods industries reduced wage payments to U.S. workers by $7.6 billion in 2004 alone.”
According to Carlos Salas, the situation in Mexico has not differed substantially from that in the United States. South of the border too, NAFTA has not lived up to its billing. According to Salas, “Since NAFTA took effect, Mexico has experienced a continual increase in the precarious nature of employment.” Not surprisingly, NAFTA has also hurt the Canadian economy. “Not only has NAFTA failed to deliver the goods it promised, its effect on the well-being of a large majority of Canadians and on the social cohesion of society has been negative,” Bruce Campbell notes in the Canadian section of the EPI report.
The facts are in: NAFTA is an economic disaster for all three nations. Nevertheless, internationalist policy analysts at leading think tanks and within the Bush administration, as well as in both Canada and Mexico, have been pushing hard for further integration of the three NAFTA nations, something many have begun to call a North American Union. Built on the creaky foundation of NAFTA, such a union would be an unmitigated disaster of world-historical proportions because NAFTA itself, as an examination of important sectors of the economy shows, has been and continues to be nothing short of catastrophic in its effects.
Trucking
Ready or not, Mexican trucks are coming to the United States. NAFTA mandated that the roads of all three signatory nations be open to trucks from all three countries, but safety concerns have kept Mexican trucks confined to a narrow corridor along the border. Now a “pilot program” of the Department of Transportation would give Mexican drivers from 100 approved Mexican trucking companies access to the entire country.
It’s a move that is supposed to be good for business, but it is really part of the plan to increase the tonnage of shipping handled by Mexican ports and to move that freight through Mexico into the United States by means of NAFTA corridors — the so-called NAFTA Superhighway (see article "Paving Over Our Borders"). Like everything else related to NAFTA, opening the borders to Mexican trucks will have consequences for American workers, putting U.S. truckers out of business — while making American roads more dangerous.
The pilot plan “is a big push by American and Mexican big business to use cheap labor,” said Jim Hoffa, president of the Teamsters Union. The wage disparity between Mexican drivers and their U.S. counterparts is substantial. According to Fleetowner magazine, the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA), for instance, “contends that competition from Mexican carriers will eventually overwhelm U.S. fleets because Mexican drivers are paid 25% to 50% less than most domestic drivers.”
The Teamsters found out how poorly Mexican drivers are paid when they sent investigative reporter Charles Bowden to Mexico to report on the condition of the Mexican trucking industry last August. Bowden talked to drivers who worked for days on end, sometimes driving for 48 hours without a break. “The men earn about $1,100 a month,” Bowden reported. And the pay is for a workload that can be handled only with assistance from narcotics.
The Mexican drivers Bowden talked to insisted that they can only stay awake on their long and frequent journeys across Mexico by using what they euphemistically term “magic dust.” According to Bowden, the truckers “are all family men who run the highways at least 25 days a month and they are adamant about two things — that nobody can run these long hauls without cocaine and crystal meth, and now and then some marijuana to level out the rush.”
The Electronics Industry
From before World War II through the 1970s, the United States’ electronics industry was an economic powerhouse. All of the world’s most advanced electronics, from consumer to industrial applications, were designed and manufactured in the United States. Firms like GE, Magnavox, Sylvania, Zenith, RCA, and others dominated electronics manufacturing and sales — and the products these companies produced were made in U.S. factories by U.S. workers. Foreign competition began to decimate the industry in the 1980s, but the death knell came with the passage of NAFTA, when even Japanese firms moved production to Mexico. The remaining U.S. producers packed up and went south, taking their high-paying jobs with them.
In 2004, Sen. Joe Lieberman released a report through his Senate office detailing the economic impact of this “offshore outsourcing.” The report, prepared by Lieberman staffer Sara E. Hagigh and Mary Jane Bolle of the Congressional Research Service, noted that the trend to move business offshore is still “contributing to historically high levels of unemployment among electronics, software and computer engineers in the United States.” The Lieberman report also noted, ominously, that “the loss of R&D infrastructure could have important ramifications for our ability to create high-wage, high-technology jobs in the future. What is at stake is the ability of the United States to remain a global leader in innovation, to maintain high-paying jobs, and to ensure future competitiveness and growth.”
Oscar F. Contreras, visiting fellow at Mexico’s El Colegio de Sonora, and Rhonda Evans of the University of California, Berkeley, were more blunt in their assessment of NAFTA’s effects on the U.S. electronics manufacturers. In a 2002 report, they wrote: “The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) that went into effect on January 1, 1994 encouraged a regional reorganization of the consumer electronics industry in general and the TV segment of the industry in particular.... All stages of TV production, including design, the manufacture of key components, and final assembly shifted from the U.S. to northern Mexico in the wake of the agreement.”
The drain on electronics continues. In Pittsburgh, 900 jobs in the industry have been lost at the city’s Sony Technology Center as the company moves capacity to Mexico. “Now, Sony Technology Center-Pittsburgh no longer manufactures anything, only assembles Grand Wega and SXRD rear-projection TVs; and that business moves to Mexico this year,” the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review reported. While Sony may move some LCD production to Pennsylvania, that too may be transitory. “The way things go with Sony is that things start in Japan, then they bring the idea to the U.S. to refine it, then when they’re really ready to ramp up production, they’ll take it to Mexico,” Edward Taylor, former head of business planning for Sony’s U.S. TV operations, told the Pittsburgh paper.
Professionals
NAFTA is not just about destroying good blue-collar jobs. White-collar American professionals will also see their jobs disappear and their standard of living fall as, because of NAFTA, professional standards and licensing practices and requirements are harmonized across the continent. The effect will be a substantial downward pressure on white-collar compensation, something strongly advocated by no less a luminary than former Chairman of the Federal Reserve Alan Greenspan.
At a conference on maintaining the competitiveness of U.S. capital markets on March 13, Greenspan said that it was essential to flood the United States with foreign professionals in order to drive down salaries of high earners. “Our skilled wages are higher than anywhere in the world,” Greenspan said, according to Bloomberg News. “If we open up a significant window for skilled workers, that would suppress the skilled-wage level and end the concentration of income.”
That could be accomplished by harmonizing licensing and professional requirements across all three nations. Doing so would result in a larger supply of licensed professionals, driving down rates paid for professional services and possibly driving some in the United States out of business, while simultaneously making it harder for new U.S. professionals to get established.
In accounting, the harmonization of licensing began very early in the evolution of NAFTA. The CPA Journal reported in 1995: “In addition to harmonizing accounting standards, there is also an initiative to extend licensing to the professionals of other NAFTA countries. Partly as a consequence of the predecessor U.S./Canada free trade agreement, the AICPA [American Institute of Certified Public Accountants] and the CICA [Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants] have developed special examinations for CAs and CPAs interested in becoming licensed members of the other professional body. In November 1993, the AICPA administered the first such examination, while CPAs took the fast shortened CA examination in May.”
The groundwork for this kind of harmonization has been laid in other professions since NAFTA, though resistance remains. A case in point is the engineering profession. Writing for the Association of Professional Engineers, Geologists and Geophysicists of Alberta, Canadian engineer Darrel Danyluk notes “that a NAFTA Mutual Recognition Agreement (MRA) was signed by Canadian, American and Mexican representatives in 1995” and that “the accord provides a means for recognizing the qualifications of engineers working temporarily in another NAFTA jurisdiction.” But, he complains, it hasn’t been implemented in the United States. “The National Society of Professional Engineers, and the Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology in the U.S. ratified the MRA without reservations in 1995. The third American national body which had to ratify the MRA, the National Council of Examiners for Engineering and Surveying, gave provisional ratification for a two-year period which now has expired. The expiration of the NCEES ratification has had the effect of making the MRA technically unapproved in the U.S.”
The Timber Industry
What is perhaps the most contentious trade dispute in modern history has been ongoing between the United States and Canada since the early 1980s over the dumping of government-subsidized Canadian timber into the U.S. market. The matter was already a crisis before NAFTA, but turned into a scandal that uniquely highlighted the trade agreement’s destruction of national sovereignty after NAFTA took effect in 1994.
Beginning as early as 1982, U.S. timber producers charged that Canadian lumber was trading at artificially low prices in the U.S. market because Canadian timber is mostly owned by provincial governments that set stumpage prices at artificially low levels resulting, essentially, in a subsidy to the Canadian timber industry. To offset the subsidy, the U.S. assessed tariffs against Canadian lumber.
In 1991 a review of U.S. tariffs was conducted by a panel convened under the authority of the Canada-U.S. Free Trade Agreement (the precursor to NAFTA). That panel found against the United States, as would NAFTA courts convened under Chapter 19 of the later agreement. The Commerce Department finally settled on a tariff of 10.8 percent in 2005. But in March of 2006, the NAFTA panel again found in Canada’s favor, stating that Canadian subsidies were too small to be of any consequence, even though, according to the Coalition for Fair Lumber Imports, “Canada’s lumber subsidies are destroying the U.S. lumber industry, threatening its workers with mounting unemployment, and denying many tree farmers a market for their timber crops.”
The NAFTA rulings forced the United States to agree to a new Softwood Lumber Agreement (SLA) with Canada that will result in a massive refund totaling $4.3 billion for duties collected on lumber imports from Canada. In exchange, Canadian lumber exporters will pay an “export charge” collected by Canada on exports to the United States whenever the price of softwood lumber in the United States falls below certain specified amounts per 1,000 board feet.
Despite the agreement, NAFTA is probably not finished wreaking havoc on U.S. timber producers. Critics charge that some Canadian provinces are not respecting the terms of the SLA. According to a March 5 Reuters report, “on Capitol Hill, Senators pressed USTR [U.S. Trade Representative] head Susan Schwab on the deal in a hearing last month. Last week, Sen. Larry Craig, an Idaho Republican, asked Schwab to begin steps for consultations. ‘I am very concerned that this agreement is about to come apart at the seams,’ Craig said,” according to the report. It will come apart even faster if NAFTA is transformed into a North American Union.
Small Business
NAFTA has been trouble for many small businesses, something businessman Brian Coons, president of Brico Welding & Fab of Chesterfield, Michigan, knows all too well. According to Crain’s Detroit Business, a business journal serving the Detroit area, Coons “lost contracts to Mexican and Canadian competitors that he said don’t have nearly the wage and health insurance expenses carried by U.S. manufacturers.” Low wages in Mexico meant competitors there could undercut prices while favorable exchange rates meant that competitors in Canada could do the same. “NAFTA has drained us dramatically,” Coons told Detroit Business. “Let’s say I had an aluminum fabrication job, 100 pieces at $38 a piece. [A customer] can send it to Canada or Mexico and get 30 percent off.”
Plastics firm Bermar and Associates is another small business in Michigan that faced trouble in the wake of NAFTA, losing bids to firms in Canada and Mexico. “We were getting underbid by 25 to 40 percent,” company president Jan Roncelli told Detroit Business reporter Terry Kosdrosky. “We lost jobs because we could not compete. That’s into the profit margin. U.S. manufacturers don’t reap the benefits of free trade.”
The anecdotal evidence that NAFTA presents substantial problems for small business corresponds with the real trend of lost market share across the board for U.S. companies. According to the U.S. Business and Industry Council (USBIC), a group that represents small- and medium-sized firms, 111 out of 114 U.S. industries saw market share shrink in the years after NAFTA. According to Paul Johnson of the North Carolina High Point Enterprise, the USBIC data show that during an eight-year post-NAFTA period, “the level of import penetration at least doubled in 26 industry sectors. By 2005, 24 industries had lost 50 percent or more of their U.S. market to imports.” For small businesses, NAFTA has meant both the loss of existing clients and future income opportunities. And because many Americans depend on small businesses for jobs, the NAFTA hit on small business means hard times for the middle class.
Agriculture and Immigration
For thousands of years corn has been grown as a staple crop in southern Mexico. Until the mid-1990s, small Mexican farmers tended the land, following the traditions of their ancestors, protected by trade barriers from competition from America’s heavily subsidized and more efficient corn growers. NAFTA changed all that. In just over a decade, wrote St. Louis Post-Dispatch reporter Bill Lambrecht in 2005, “An estimated 1 million farmers in rural Mexico have lost their livelihoods.”
Farming jobs lost in Mexico have had a direct effect on the United States in the form of both immigration and drugs. “The idea was that bringing greater growth to Mexico, fewer Mexicans would need to leave. Mexico said, ‘we want to export our tomatoes, not our people.’ But, in fact, it led to greater migration,” said Deborah Meyers of the Migration Policy Institute. Farmers who stayed behind turned to cultivating marijuana. According to the Post-Dispatch, “the amount of marijuana seized annually along the Mexican border has doubled to 1.1 million pounds since 1994, the year NAFTA took effect.”
NAFTA has had other effects on agriculture as well. In the wake of the trade agreement, large farms growing fresh fruit and vegetables sprung up in the Mexican sun with the intent of selling cheap produce in the U.S. market. Not only did this have the potential to undercut U.S. farmers growing the same crops, the new farms further destabilized the Mexican agriculture market. As the Washington Post reported on January 7, after NAFTA, “Huge farms have been developed to grow artichokes, tomatoes and other produce for the U.S. market. But those farms, many launched with American investment, typically pay about $13 a day. That’s not enough to keep workers from leaving: They can make three to four times as much in even the lowliest U.S. jobs.”
What’s worse, produce deemed unfit for the U.S. market is sold in Mexico at cut-rate prices, driving out small producers. Then they go north too. Mexican farmer Ruben Rivera is one such small producer whose livelihood has been destroyed by NAFTA. According to the Washington Post, “He used to grow tomatoes and onions, hiring 150 workers to help at harvest. Now he doesn’t even bother to plant.” It’s cheaper to buy leftover produce from the big producers than it is for him to grow his own. “For people who can grow huge scale for export, NAFTA has been good,” Rivera, whose three sons live in Georgia and send $800 home to Mexico per month, told the Washington Post. “For people like us, it’s been a bloodbath.”
The Auto Industry
The statistics are so incredible as to be almost unbelievable. The Big Three automakers, direct employers of hundreds of thousands of American workers, are hemorrhaging colossal sums of money and laying off workers in droves. Last year Ford alone lost $12.7 billion; Chrysler lost only $1.48 billion, but it was enough for Germany’s Daimler to start looking for a way to divest themselves of their unstable American partner. The huge losses are leading to equally large layoffs. Ford, for one, is laying off over 30,000 employees in North America, many of them in the United States, and is closing a number of U.S. factories. The controversial closure in Atlanta, long the home of Ford Taurus production, came despite the fact that the plant “has ranked among the top 10 most productive assembly plants in North America, as reported by Harbour Consulting,” according to a Ford Fact Sheet. Like Ford, General Motors is cutting 30,000 jobs and closing a number of U.S. factories.
The problems of the Big Three can’t all be attributed to NAFTA. But while Americans lose high-paying jobs in the auto industry, Mexican workers who are paid much, much less can expect more work. In 2005, in the midst of losing $10.6 billion, GM was ramping up the production of trucks at its Mexican factories. “We’re short on trucks. Dealers don’t have them in all the colors and with all the options that people want,” Gilbert Duhn, a GM manager, told the San Antonio Express-News. “We’ve started building more trucks in Mexico.”
Ford is doing the same thing, producing its new family of midsize cars, including the Ford Fusion, Mercury Milan, and Lincoln Zephyr, at its Hermosillo plant in Mexico. In fact, Mexico has become a major center for the manufacture of cars and trucks that are intended for sale in the United States. According to Business Week, “Three-quarters of Mexican-made vehicles are exported to the U.S., largely by Detroit’s Big Three but also by German giant Volkswagen.” Those are cars that could have been built in America by Americans.
In the face of recent catastrophic losses, the pressure on U.S. automakers to move to a low-cost environment may be overwhelming. In a May 2002 paper, Korean economist Ho Yeon Kim pointed out that Mexico has always had low “site costs” (defined as “low wages, amenities and taxes”) and that NAFTA had significantly lowered Mexico’s “situation costs” (defined as costs for transport of raw materials and finished products), but that Mexico would not be attractive for small-car production unless other “non-tariff barriers” were overcome or reduced. The increased production of GM trucks and Ford midsize sedans in Mexico suggests that, under the current business climate, Detroit no longer views those “non-tariff barriers” as impediments to Mexican production. So while the loss of tens of thousands of jobs in Detroit’s U.S. factories may not have been directly caused by NAFTA, they may be prevented from ever returning to the United States — largely because of NAFTA.
Longshoremen
If you are a longshoreman and you work at one of the nation’s West Coast ports, especially Los Angeles or Long Beach, NAFTA has an ugly surprise in store for you: your job will soon be gone.
In order to facilitate the shipment of Chinese goods to the United States, freight will be brought to huge and improved ports, like that at Lazaro Cardenas in Mexico, according to author and investigative journalist Jerome Corsi, “bypassing the Longshoreman’s Union in the process.” Interestingly, the port in Lazaro Cardenas is owned by Hutchison Port Holdings, a subsidiary of Hutchison Whampoa, the Chinese firm operated by billionaire Li Ka-shing that now operates the Panama Canal’s anchor ports of Cristobal and Balboa following a controversial takeover in the 1990s.
After unloading at Mexican ports, freight will be loaded onto Mexican trucks for shipment to the United States, bypassing Teamsters and U.S. independent owner-operators as well as larger American trucking firms. According to Corsi, the Mexican trucks “will drive on what will be the nation’s most modern highway straight into the heart of America.”
The plan to ship Asian goods into the United States through NAFTA corridors linking up with Mexican ports has even begun to draw the ire of socialists. Richard Vogel, writing for the socialist Monthly Review, argues that this NAFTA-based plan “signals the beginning of the assault on labor in the north, which could eventually result in the offshoring of hundreds of thousands of transportation jobs to the south and undermine the working class on both sides of the border significantly.” Among those who will be most affected will be America’s dockworkers.
NAFTA Only the Start
When NAFTA was being debated in the early 1990s, the American people were not told that the proposed arrangement would be the starting point for further political integration of Canada and Mexico with the United States. But the planners behind NAFTA had that goal in mind all along. NAFTA, with all its economic dislocations, was meant to be just the beginning of a larger plot. Speaking at the Canadian-American Business Council Luncheon on June 24, 2003 in Washington, D.C., then-U.S. Secretary of Commerce Donald L. Evans, referring at the time to efforts to build a Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA), noted that NAFTA was only a starting point for regional integration. “NAFTA was just the beginning,” Evans enthused. “President Bush has said that ‘We have a great vision before us: a fully democratic hemisphere, bound together by good will and free trade.’”
The FTAA ran into intense opposition but internationalist planners didn’t give up. Instead, following the motto that NAFTA is just a beginning, they hit upon a new plan: North American Union. In a 2005 op-ed in the Wall Street Journal obnoxiously entitled “North America the Beautiful,” internationalist theorists John Manley, Pedro Aspe, and William Weld argued that, over the last decade, “the pace of economic integration within North America has outstripped the capacity of the Nafta framework.” To rectify that, they proposed that the leaders of the NAFTA nations “should announce a plan to establish a North American security and economic community by 2010.”
The op-ed came just a few days after a meeting on March 23, 2005 of the heads of state of the NAFTA nations. At the meeting, then-Canadian Prime Minister Paul Martin joined with President Bush and former Mexican President Vicente Fox in taking the first step toward that economic community by constructing the Security and Prosperity Partnership of North America — the next step on the road to a North America Union.
The economic dislocations of NAFTA have been terrible; just imagine how bad they will be under a more fully implemented plan for regional governance. If ever there was a time for the country to abandon NAFTA, now is that time — before the nation is maneuvered into a North American Union it can ill afford.
Published in The New American.
Political commentary and analysis of current Texas Policies. Focuses on pending legislation with action alerts. Applies a “Follow the Money progressive approach” to local and state officials' roles in public policy.
Saturday, July 14, 2007
Thursday, July 12, 2007
We need Renters' Bill of Rights
By Faith Chatham - July 11, 2007
Tax-assisted or tax abated housing has been one of the more common public private partnerships for many decades. The abuses in this system are legendary. Despite many Federal and state regulations for rent subsidy vouchers, there appears to be little transparency to alert potential renters to the practices of apartment owners before they move in. Citizens on fixed incomes frequently discover that apartment management companies and owners are deliquent in paying for vital services and refuse to keep the units up to code. These discoveries are usually made after the resident has depleted limited resources in moving into a complex.
There is no requirement that apartment owners disclose to potential tenants:
1. Failures within the last year to correct code violations before the inspector has returned for a reinspection.
2. Crime in the complex.
3. Who owns the complex.
State law requires that nursing homes post complaints against their establishment and nursing home code violations, (and their resolution) in a public place and make them available to all potential new residents VEFORE the paperwork is signed for a resident to move into the home. A similar law is needed for apartment complexes.
Apartment investors frequently hide behind management companies. It is difficult to know who actually owns an apartment complex.
For decades it has been acknowledged that many investors get tax abatements and/or tax exempt bonds to construct low income or senior/handicapped housing and switch the housing to regular housing as soon as the bonds are paid off. The tax payers investment in private public partnerships for subsidized housing frequently yields greater return to the investor than to the taxpayer or targeted group needing housing assistance.
The news media occasionaly covers stories of tenants having their electricity, garbage pickup or water turned off although they have paid their rent. Tenants have a difficult time learning of financial difficulties of landlords until it has escalated into a crisis. When the garbage trucks had not emptied the dumpster for over a week at my complex, I called the disposal company and was told that unless I was the owner or authorized representative of the owner they would not tell me if the owners had paid their bill. Residents who have submetered electricity have similar difficulties learning if the complex has paid the electric utility bill.
Apartment complexes run financial background checks on tenants before they lease them apartments. Tenants have difficulty learning who owns the majority of the corporations which own their complexes. Without knowing who owns the complex, tenants can move from one complex trying to escape bad management and move into another one with similar problems because they have the same owners.
Slum lords who abuse the system hide behind holding companies, investment companies and hired management companies and escape the scrunity of their neighbors who are bothered by the nusiance of crime-ridden apartment complexes which have numerous sanitation and safety code violations. Some even run for political office or get appointed to city boards and commissions.
We need stiffer fines for landlords who do not correct code violations by the time the inspectors return for the reinspection. We need a tenants Bill of Rights which requires apartment complexes to disclose to ever prospective tenant before they sign a lease:
1. The code violations which were not corrected by the next reinspection for the past 12 months
2. The number of reported crimes and the types of crimes
3. Names, addresses and contact information for all investors who own at least 30% of the complex.
All tenants should be provided a release from the complex instructing trash collection and utility companies to reveal to the tenant the status of payment for services by the complex. Tenants who have submetered electricity, water and/or gas service should be allowed to learn the status of payment by the complex for those services.
4. All tenants should be allowed to form tenants associations.
5. Complexes should be fined if they advertise amenenties which they do not support or maintain. If they advertise swimming pools or gyms, but do not maintain them and allow tenants to use them, they should be penalized.
I think that a process similar to that
Tax-assisted or tax abated housing has been one of the more common public private partnerships for many decades. The abuses in this system are legendary. Despite many Federal and state regulations for rent subsidy vouchers, there appears to be little transparency to alert potential renters to the practices of apartment owners before they move in. Citizens on fixed incomes frequently discover that apartment management companies and owners are deliquent in paying for vital services and refuse to keep the units up to code. These discoveries are usually made after the resident has depleted limited resources in moving into a complex.
There is no requirement that apartment owners disclose to potential tenants:
1. Failures within the last year to correct code violations before the inspector has returned for a reinspection.
2. Crime in the complex.
3. Who owns the complex.
State law requires that nursing homes post complaints against their establishment and nursing home code violations, (and their resolution) in a public place and make them available to all potential new residents VEFORE the paperwork is signed for a resident to move into the home. A similar law is needed for apartment complexes.
Apartment investors frequently hide behind management companies. It is difficult to know who actually owns an apartment complex.
For decades it has been acknowledged that many investors get tax abatements and/or tax exempt bonds to construct low income or senior/handicapped housing and switch the housing to regular housing as soon as the bonds are paid off. The tax payers investment in private public partnerships for subsidized housing frequently yields greater return to the investor than to the taxpayer or targeted group needing housing assistance.
The news media occasionaly covers stories of tenants having their electricity, garbage pickup or water turned off although they have paid their rent. Tenants have a difficult time learning of financial difficulties of landlords until it has escalated into a crisis. When the garbage trucks had not emptied the dumpster for over a week at my complex, I called the disposal company and was told that unless I was the owner or authorized representative of the owner they would not tell me if the owners had paid their bill. Residents who have submetered electricity have similar difficulties learning if the complex has paid the electric utility bill.
Apartment complexes run financial background checks on tenants before they lease them apartments. Tenants have difficulty learning who owns the majority of the corporations which own their complexes. Without knowing who owns the complex, tenants can move from one complex trying to escape bad management and move into another one with similar problems because they have the same owners.
Slum lords who abuse the system hide behind holding companies, investment companies and hired management companies and escape the scrunity of their neighbors who are bothered by the nusiance of crime-ridden apartment complexes which have numerous sanitation and safety code violations. Some even run for political office or get appointed to city boards and commissions.
We need stiffer fines for landlords who do not correct code violations by the time the inspectors return for the reinspection. We need a tenants Bill of Rights which requires apartment complexes to disclose to ever prospective tenant before they sign a lease:
1. The code violations which were not corrected by the next reinspection for the past 12 months
2. The number of reported crimes and the types of crimes
3. Names, addresses and contact information for all investors who own at least 30% of the complex.
All tenants should be provided a release from the complex instructing trash collection and utility companies to reveal to the tenant the status of payment for services by the complex. Tenants who have submetered electricity, water and/or gas service should be allowed to learn the status of payment by the complex for those services.
4. All tenants should be allowed to form tenants associations.
5. Complexes should be fined if they advertise amenenties which they do not support or maintain. If they advertise swimming pools or gyms, but do not maintain them and allow tenants to use them, they should be penalized.
I think that a process similar to that
Elderly say the city is letting their homes rot
By MIKE LEE - Star-Telegram Staff Writer - Wed, Jul. 11, 2007
KYEV TATUM FORT WORTH -- Like many people in retirement complexes, the residents of the Villas at Eastwood Terrace loved getting together with their neighbors.
They held bingo games, potluck suppers and other activities in the meeting room of the city-supported apartment complex for senior citizens.
But when residents began complaining about conditions -- the leaks, the mold, the need for energy-saving screen doors -- the bingo games and other activities came to an abrupt halt.
"They didn't have anything to do; they'd sit around at home and watch television," said Bobby Allen, 59, who moved into the complex to be close to his mother.
Residents believe the complex managers canceled their activities for about six months in retaliation for complaints, and they want some answers from the city.
Complex managers did not respond to a request from the Star-Telegram seeking comment.
High praise
It was billed as "the miracle on East Berry Street," a city-backed housing development for senior citizens that would help revitalize the Stop Six neighborhood in southeast Fort Worth.
The $10.5 million, 160-unit complex opened in May 2003 on 14.5 acres at 4700 E. Berry St. with amenities that seniors could appreciate: carpeting, covered parking, major appliances, and a beauty salon, game room, library, exercise room and swimming pool.
The complex is owned by the nonprofit Villas of Eastwood Terrace, which was set up by the city to oversee the development, and was funded through the sale of tax-exempt bonds issued by the Fort Worth Housing Finance Corp., an arm of the city. Today, the Villas board of directors includes city Housing Director Jerome Walker.
Calls unheeded
Residents say it didn't take long for the problems to begin.
Pearl Gordon, 81, was one of the first to move in. She thought the complex was supposed to have full-time security guards, but the guards stopped working soon after the units were filled, she said.
Maintenance men charged her $25 for services such as hanging pictures and unlocking doors. And the managers have ignored her complaints about a water leak around her front door that has led to mold along her baseboards.
"I turned it in, but no one ever came," she said.
Across the way, Allen said water leaks under his front door when it rains because of the way the landscaping was graded. He, too, has gotten no response.
"I've been through three managers about this," he said.
Bonnie Burns said one of her bedrooms flooded from a leaky outdoor faucet. The manager fixed it by screwing a cap over the end of the faucet and telling residents not to use it, she said. Burns had to replace her bedroom furniture.
"I left for three weeks; there wasn't anything done," she said. "I tolerate it because I like my neighbors."
Screen doors
The latest squabble has been over screen doors. The residents want them so that they can catch breezes and avoid running their air conditioners.
Both city staff and the management company have turned them down. Walker, the city housing director, said screen doors would clash with the complex's design and cost too much to maintain.
But Walker said he wasn't aware of many of the other complaints, and officials from the management company, Quest Asset Management, could not be reached to comment.
The Rev. Kyev Tatum, a community activist whose father lives in the complex and who volunteered to represent the residents, said the city has a history of ignoring complaints from low-income residents.
"The buck stops with Mike Moncrief and the City Council," Tatum said. "They wouldn't allow this on the west side."
Walker denied that the city is responsible for the problems, but he said the complex has had a hard time bringing in enough revenue to cover its expenses, despite occupancy rates typically higher than 90 percent.
Walker wouldn't say whether the city or the complex managers were considering raising the rent. But Quest is scheduled to present options to the City Council this month.
Going to City Hall
About a dozen residents took their complaints to Tuesday night's City Council meeting.
After listening to Tatum, who spoke for the group, Mayor Mike Moncrief said the council will look into the complaints.
"I don't think any member of this council would condone any of our senior citizens, regardless of where they are, being intimidated," he said.
Read more
KYEV TATUM FORT WORTH -- Like many people in retirement complexes, the residents of the Villas at Eastwood Terrace loved getting together with their neighbors.
They held bingo games, potluck suppers and other activities in the meeting room of the city-supported apartment complex for senior citizens.
But when residents began complaining about conditions -- the leaks, the mold, the need for energy-saving screen doors -- the bingo games and other activities came to an abrupt halt.
"They didn't have anything to do; they'd sit around at home and watch television," said Bobby Allen, 59, who moved into the complex to be close to his mother.
Residents believe the complex managers canceled their activities for about six months in retaliation for complaints, and they want some answers from the city.
Complex managers did not respond to a request from the Star-Telegram seeking comment.
High praise
It was billed as "the miracle on East Berry Street," a city-backed housing development for senior citizens that would help revitalize the Stop Six neighborhood in southeast Fort Worth.
The $10.5 million, 160-unit complex opened in May 2003 on 14.5 acres at 4700 E. Berry St. with amenities that seniors could appreciate: carpeting, covered parking, major appliances, and a beauty salon, game room, library, exercise room and swimming pool.
The complex is owned by the nonprofit Villas of Eastwood Terrace, which was set up by the city to oversee the development, and was funded through the sale of tax-exempt bonds issued by the Fort Worth Housing Finance Corp., an arm of the city. Today, the Villas board of directors includes city Housing Director Jerome Walker.
Calls unheeded
Residents say it didn't take long for the problems to begin.
Pearl Gordon, 81, was one of the first to move in. She thought the complex was supposed to have full-time security guards, but the guards stopped working soon after the units were filled, she said.
Maintenance men charged her $25 for services such as hanging pictures and unlocking doors. And the managers have ignored her complaints about a water leak around her front door that has led to mold along her baseboards.
"I turned it in, but no one ever came," she said.
Across the way, Allen said water leaks under his front door when it rains because of the way the landscaping was graded. He, too, has gotten no response.
"I've been through three managers about this," he said.
Bonnie Burns said one of her bedrooms flooded from a leaky outdoor faucet. The manager fixed it by screwing a cap over the end of the faucet and telling residents not to use it, she said. Burns had to replace her bedroom furniture.
"I left for three weeks; there wasn't anything done," she said. "I tolerate it because I like my neighbors."
Screen doors
The latest squabble has been over screen doors. The residents want them so that they can catch breezes and avoid running their air conditioners.
Both city staff and the management company have turned them down. Walker, the city housing director, said screen doors would clash with the complex's design and cost too much to maintain.
But Walker said he wasn't aware of many of the other complaints, and officials from the management company, Quest Asset Management, could not be reached to comment.
The Rev. Kyev Tatum, a community activist whose father lives in the complex and who volunteered to represent the residents, said the city has a history of ignoring complaints from low-income residents.
"The buck stops with Mike Moncrief and the City Council," Tatum said. "They wouldn't allow this on the west side."
Walker denied that the city is responsible for the problems, but he said the complex has had a hard time bringing in enough revenue to cover its expenses, despite occupancy rates typically higher than 90 percent.
Walker wouldn't say whether the city or the complex managers were considering raising the rent. But Quest is scheduled to present options to the City Council this month.
Going to City Hall
About a dozen residents took their complaints to Tuesday night's City Council meeting.
After listening to Tatum, who spoke for the group, Mayor Mike Moncrief said the council will look into the complaints.
"I don't think any member of this council would condone any of our senior citizens, regardless of where they are, being intimidated," he said.
Read more
Thursday, July 05, 2007
New Dallas jailers work without training
Dallas' new hires wait months for academy; some say practice can be costly, dangerous
By KEVIN KRAUSE - The Dallas Morning News - Thursday, July 5, 2007
Dozens of newly hired Dallas County jail guards are going straight to work, supervising inmates for months before undergoing any formal training or taking the state's licensing exam.
Though officials say there have been no incidents attributed to the untrained guards, the practice of immediately putting them in contact with inmates is considered by some experts to be potentially dangerous – and costly.
The practice is legal: Temporary jailer licenses from the state allow recruits as young as 18 to work inside jails while they await a spot in a training academy. A sheriff's department has one year to get them trained and certified as jailers. The new hires are supposed to be under the constant supervision of training officers.
But with Dallas County hustling to fill a couple of hundred new positions to address a jail-staffing crisis, the quality and extent of that supervision are in question.
Most of the 215 new jail guard positions created since late last year have been filled. But there are only about 115 training officers to supervise them.
Some recruits are spending up to six months on the job before being admitted to the four-week academy, officials said, often coming into direct contact with inmates.
The new recruits haven't yet learned rules and regulations or important skills such as proper restraint and search techniques. Their placement also poses the question of liability for the county.
If an inmate is injured in an encounter with a rookie guard, for example, the county could be held liable for failing to properly train the guard.
A good thing
Sheriff Lupe Valdez referred questions to her spokesman, Michael Ortiz, who said a little on-the-job training before hitting the classroom can be a good thing.
He said he supervised three trainees when he was a detention training officer in 1997. Training officers are jailers who take on the extra duties for $100 extra a month.
"You're never outside each other's line of sight," he said.
Deputy Ortiz said he would assign certain duties to his trainees and then watch them. Training officers have to fill out evaluation sheets on the recruits each month. Any deficiencies are corrected the following month, he said.
"The liability is always there, but the training officer knows that," Deputy Ortiz said. "It makes them train better."
Staffing shortages at the Dallas County jails have contributed to failed state inspections four years in a row. The county has not been able to meet the state's minimum staffing requirement of one guard for every 48 inmates.
As a result, county commissioners have been adding guard positions as fast as they can. Since Sheriff Valdez took office in 2005, 355 jail guard positions have been added, according to the county budget office.
And Sheriff Valdez has been counting them toward the 1-48 ratio as soon as they're hired.
The most recent jail inspection by the Texas Commission on Jail Standards in late March noted that new employees were being assigned to jail duties even before their paperwork was sent to the state for a temporary jailer license.
Common practice
Corrections experts say putting newly hired guards to work right away is a risk that's all too common at prisons and jails because of problems with recruitment, training and retention of jail guards.
Kenneth McGinnis, a partner with the consulting firm MGT of America, said most counties try to place recruits into schools before on-the-job training so they have at least some skills going in.
But often, inexperienced recruits find themselves guarding violent offenders not long after filling out a job application, he said.
"Unfortunately, it's a frequent occurrence," said Mr. McGinnis, a former director of prison systems in Michigan and Illinois. "In some cases they have little choice."
Not all large Texas sheriff's departments put new hires directly to work.
Executive Chief Deputy Bob Knowles of the Tarrant County Sheriff's Office said his department used to do it that way. But that policy was later viewed as risky, he said. Mind games between inmates and jailers are common, he said, and inexperienced guards could find themselves taken advantage of or conned.
"Liability-wise, I'm not sure it's a good idea to put new people in the jail where a lot of things can happen," said Chief Knowles, who used to command the Dallas County jails.
Well-trained
Deputy Chief Dennis McKnight, Bexar County's jail administrator, said recruits get on-the-job training after spending more than two months in the academy. Unlike other jails, Bexar County uses deputies in the jail rather than civilian jailers, known here as detention service officers.
"We want our officers as well-trained as possible before we put them on the floor," he said.
The additional training makes guards more confident, which is reflected in their attitude and manner while working among inmates, Chief McKnight said.
Lt. John Martin of the Harris County Sheriff's Office said newly hired guards spend their first two weeks on a training floor that houses low-risk inmates who spend their days on work details. After that, the rookies are supervised by experienced guards while they await a spot in the academy, he said.
"We try to limit their direct contact with inmates," Lt. Martin said.
Stan Thedford, president of the Dallas County Sheriff's Association, said he would like new hires to go to the academy first. The biggest threat to security inside the jails, he said, is fraternization between inmates and guards.
That can be avoided, he said, by properly training jailers before they're allowed to interact with inmates.
4- to 6-month wait
Capt. David Mitchell, who oversees training and personnel at the Sheriff's Department, said it's taking four to six months to get new hires into the academy.
The classes are filling up quickly, he said, with about 40 recruits to every class. Capt. Mitchell said he's holding about 10 classes this year. Normally, it's half that number, he said.
"We're running them back to back to stay caught up," he said. "We've only got one year to get them trained."
Once they pass the state's licensing exam, rookie guards are issued a permanent jailer's license. Before that, they are on probationary status and can be fired for any reason without a hearing.
Deputy recruits, by contrast, must complete the academy and pass the peace officer licensing exam before they are allowed to patrol the streets.
Ideally, jail guard recruits shouldn't have to work inside a jail for more than two weeks before entering the school, Capt. Mitchell said.
"There's too much of an opportunity for them to develop bad habits," he said. "We have to correct those in the academy."
Recruits, he said, need training on what is the allowable force to use, as well as defensive tactics, handcuffing and other specialized skills.
"That is one of the reasons we want to get them in school as soon as possible," he said.
Working in the jails before the academy gives recruits an opportunity to see if they'll enjoy the work, said Deputy Ortiz, the department spokesman. Some don't. One recruit called it quits after three days, Deputy Ortiz said. That saves the county the expense of having to put the recruit through the academy, he said.
County Commissioner John Wiley Price, chairman of the county's jail population committee, said he hasn't heard of any problems involving trainees. He said sheriff's commanders are aware of the issue and have stressed the need for better supervision of jail guards.
Mr. Price said Sheriff Valdez inherited the staffing shortage problem and is doing the best she can to address it.
"When it's all said and done, they are managing well under extremely dire circumstances," he said.
See WFAA
By KEVIN KRAUSE - The Dallas Morning News - Thursday, July 5, 2007
Dozens of newly hired Dallas County jail guards are going straight to work, supervising inmates for months before undergoing any formal training or taking the state's licensing exam.
Though officials say there have been no incidents attributed to the untrained guards, the practice of immediately putting them in contact with inmates is considered by some experts to be potentially dangerous – and costly.
The practice is legal: Temporary jailer licenses from the state allow recruits as young as 18 to work inside jails while they await a spot in a training academy. A sheriff's department has one year to get them trained and certified as jailers. The new hires are supposed to be under the constant supervision of training officers.
But with Dallas County hustling to fill a couple of hundred new positions to address a jail-staffing crisis, the quality and extent of that supervision are in question.
Most of the 215 new jail guard positions created since late last year have been filled. But there are only about 115 training officers to supervise them.
Some recruits are spending up to six months on the job before being admitted to the four-week academy, officials said, often coming into direct contact with inmates.
The new recruits haven't yet learned rules and regulations or important skills such as proper restraint and search techniques. Their placement also poses the question of liability for the county.
If an inmate is injured in an encounter with a rookie guard, for example, the county could be held liable for failing to properly train the guard.
A good thing
Sheriff Lupe Valdez referred questions to her spokesman, Michael Ortiz, who said a little on-the-job training before hitting the classroom can be a good thing.
He said he supervised three trainees when he was a detention training officer in 1997. Training officers are jailers who take on the extra duties for $100 extra a month.
"You're never outside each other's line of sight," he said.
Deputy Ortiz said he would assign certain duties to his trainees and then watch them. Training officers have to fill out evaluation sheets on the recruits each month. Any deficiencies are corrected the following month, he said.
"The liability is always there, but the training officer knows that," Deputy Ortiz said. "It makes them train better."
Staffing shortages at the Dallas County jails have contributed to failed state inspections four years in a row. The county has not been able to meet the state's minimum staffing requirement of one guard for every 48 inmates.
As a result, county commissioners have been adding guard positions as fast as they can. Since Sheriff Valdez took office in 2005, 355 jail guard positions have been added, according to the county budget office.
And Sheriff Valdez has been counting them toward the 1-48 ratio as soon as they're hired.
The most recent jail inspection by the Texas Commission on Jail Standards in late March noted that new employees were being assigned to jail duties even before their paperwork was sent to the state for a temporary jailer license.
Common practice
Corrections experts say putting newly hired guards to work right away is a risk that's all too common at prisons and jails because of problems with recruitment, training and retention of jail guards.
Kenneth McGinnis, a partner with the consulting firm MGT of America, said most counties try to place recruits into schools before on-the-job training so they have at least some skills going in.
But often, inexperienced recruits find themselves guarding violent offenders not long after filling out a job application, he said.
"Unfortunately, it's a frequent occurrence," said Mr. McGinnis, a former director of prison systems in Michigan and Illinois. "In some cases they have little choice."
Not all large Texas sheriff's departments put new hires directly to work.
Executive Chief Deputy Bob Knowles of the Tarrant County Sheriff's Office said his department used to do it that way. But that policy was later viewed as risky, he said. Mind games between inmates and jailers are common, he said, and inexperienced guards could find themselves taken advantage of or conned.
"Liability-wise, I'm not sure it's a good idea to put new people in the jail where a lot of things can happen," said Chief Knowles, who used to command the Dallas County jails.
Well-trained
Deputy Chief Dennis McKnight, Bexar County's jail administrator, said recruits get on-the-job training after spending more than two months in the academy. Unlike other jails, Bexar County uses deputies in the jail rather than civilian jailers, known here as detention service officers.
"We want our officers as well-trained as possible before we put them on the floor," he said.
The additional training makes guards more confident, which is reflected in their attitude and manner while working among inmates, Chief McKnight said.
Lt. John Martin of the Harris County Sheriff's Office said newly hired guards spend their first two weeks on a training floor that houses low-risk inmates who spend their days on work details. After that, the rookies are supervised by experienced guards while they await a spot in the academy, he said.
"We try to limit their direct contact with inmates," Lt. Martin said.
Stan Thedford, president of the Dallas County Sheriff's Association, said he would like new hires to go to the academy first. The biggest threat to security inside the jails, he said, is fraternization between inmates and guards.
That can be avoided, he said, by properly training jailers before they're allowed to interact with inmates.
4- to 6-month wait
Capt. David Mitchell, who oversees training and personnel at the Sheriff's Department, said it's taking four to six months to get new hires into the academy.
The classes are filling up quickly, he said, with about 40 recruits to every class. Capt. Mitchell said he's holding about 10 classes this year. Normally, it's half that number, he said.
"We're running them back to back to stay caught up," he said. "We've only got one year to get them trained."
Once they pass the state's licensing exam, rookie guards are issued a permanent jailer's license. Before that, they are on probationary status and can be fired for any reason without a hearing.
Deputy recruits, by contrast, must complete the academy and pass the peace officer licensing exam before they are allowed to patrol the streets.
Ideally, jail guard recruits shouldn't have to work inside a jail for more than two weeks before entering the school, Capt. Mitchell said.
"There's too much of an opportunity for them to develop bad habits," he said. "We have to correct those in the academy."
Recruits, he said, need training on what is the allowable force to use, as well as defensive tactics, handcuffing and other specialized skills.
"That is one of the reasons we want to get them in school as soon as possible," he said.
Working in the jails before the academy gives recruits an opportunity to see if they'll enjoy the work, said Deputy Ortiz, the department spokesman. Some don't. One recruit called it quits after three days, Deputy Ortiz said. That saves the county the expense of having to put the recruit through the academy, he said.
County Commissioner John Wiley Price, chairman of the county's jail population committee, said he hasn't heard of any problems involving trainees. He said sheriff's commanders are aware of the issue and have stressed the need for better supervision of jail guards.
Mr. Price said Sheriff Valdez inherited the staffing shortage problem and is doing the best she can to address it.
"When it's all said and done, they are managing well under extremely dire circumstances," he said.
See WFAA
Labels:
Dallas,
jail guards,
Lupe Valdez,
temporary jailer license,
training
Wednesday, July 04, 2007
House Balks at Bush Order for New Powers
By JIM ABRAMS - Associated Press Writer - July 3, 2007
WASHINGTON — President Bush this month is giving an obscure White House office new powers over regulations affecting health, worker safety and the environment. Calling it a power grab, Democrats running Congress are intent on stopping him.
The House voted last week to prohibit the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs from spending federal money on Executive Order 13422, signed by Bush last January and due to take effect July 24.
The order requires federal officials to show that private companies, people or institutions failed to address a problem before agencies can write regulations to tackle it. It also gives political appointees greater authority over how the regulations are written.
The House measure "stops this president or any president from seizing the power to rewrite almost every law that Congress passes, laws that protect public health, the environment, safety, civil rights, privacy and on and on," said Rep. Brad Miller, D-N.C., its sponsor.
"OIRA has quietly grown into the most powerful regulatory agency in Washington," the House Science investigations subcommittee, chaired by Miller, said in a report in April.
The administration contends Bush's order merely strengthens a similar directive issued by President Clinton in 1993 giving the White House budget office oversight of federal agency rulemaking.
Andrea Wuebker, a spokeswoman for the Office of Management and Budget, which manages the White House regulatory affairs office, said the order, along with an OMB good guidance bulletin, "will help increase the quality, accountability and transparency of agency guidance documents."
Bush's executive order:
_Requires agencies to identify "market failures," where the private sector fell short in dealing with a problem, as a factor in proposing a rule. The White House regulatory affairs office is given authority to assess those conclusions.
_States that no rulemaking can go forward without the approval of an agency's Regulatory Policy Office, to be headed by a presidential appointee.
_Directs each agency to provide an estimate of costs and benefits of regulations.
_Requires agencies to inform the White House regulatory affairs office of proposed significant guidance documents on complying with rules. Critics say this will create a new bottleneck delaying the issuance of guidelines needed to comply with federal regulations.
"This can only further delay implementing health, safety and environmental protections," said Gary Bass, executive director of OMB Watch, a private watchdog group that joined numerous labor and good-government groups, including the AFL-CIO, Public Citizen and the Union of Concerned Scientists, in opposing Bush's order.
Miller tried unsuccessfully at a hearing in April to persuade the White House regulatory affairs office's former acting administrator, Steven Aitken, to reveal what private groups might have been involved in rewriting the Clinton-era order.
Aitken stressed that the Clinton order also used market failure as a criteria in advancing new rules and directing agencies to appoint regulatory policy officers, many of whom were political appointees. Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, R-Calif., backed Aitken up at the hearing.
"The pattern is that we are challenging the president's authority, hoping to find a mistake and then making a lot of political hay about it," Rohrabacher said.
The nonpartisan Congressional Research Service noted in an analysis last February that President Reagan made the White House regulatory affairs office the central clearinghouse for substantive rulemaking, reviewing 2,000 to 3,000 proposed regulations per year. With Clinton's 1993 order, White House reviews of proposed regulations dropped to between 500 and 700 a year, the researchers said.
Bill Kovacs, vice president for regulatory affairs with the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, said the White House's regulatory affairs office now has about 35 people to keep track of the 4,000 rules federal agencies issue every year.
"It's only reasonable that you have some way of monitoring what your agencies are doing," Kovacs said, adding that the White House needs to assert control over the process.
___
The House bill is HR 2829.
On the Net:
Text of Jan. 18 Executive Order 13422
Copyright 2007, The Associated Press. Read more
WASHINGTON — President Bush this month is giving an obscure White House office new powers over regulations affecting health, worker safety and the environment. Calling it a power grab, Democrats running Congress are intent on stopping him.
The House voted last week to prohibit the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs from spending federal money on Executive Order 13422, signed by Bush last January and due to take effect July 24.
The order requires federal officials to show that private companies, people or institutions failed to address a problem before agencies can write regulations to tackle it. It also gives political appointees greater authority over how the regulations are written.
The House measure "stops this president or any president from seizing the power to rewrite almost every law that Congress passes, laws that protect public health, the environment, safety, civil rights, privacy and on and on," said Rep. Brad Miller, D-N.C., its sponsor.
"OIRA has quietly grown into the most powerful regulatory agency in Washington," the House Science investigations subcommittee, chaired by Miller, said in a report in April.
The administration contends Bush's order merely strengthens a similar directive issued by President Clinton in 1993 giving the White House budget office oversight of federal agency rulemaking.
Andrea Wuebker, a spokeswoman for the Office of Management and Budget, which manages the White House regulatory affairs office, said the order, along with an OMB good guidance bulletin, "will help increase the quality, accountability and transparency of agency guidance documents."
Bush's executive order:
_Requires agencies to identify "market failures," where the private sector fell short in dealing with a problem, as a factor in proposing a rule. The White House regulatory affairs office is given authority to assess those conclusions.
_States that no rulemaking can go forward without the approval of an agency's Regulatory Policy Office, to be headed by a presidential appointee.
_Directs each agency to provide an estimate of costs and benefits of regulations.
_Requires agencies to inform the White House regulatory affairs office of proposed significant guidance documents on complying with rules. Critics say this will create a new bottleneck delaying the issuance of guidelines needed to comply with federal regulations.
"This can only further delay implementing health, safety and environmental protections," said Gary Bass, executive director of OMB Watch, a private watchdog group that joined numerous labor and good-government groups, including the AFL-CIO, Public Citizen and the Union of Concerned Scientists, in opposing Bush's order.
Miller tried unsuccessfully at a hearing in April to persuade the White House regulatory affairs office's former acting administrator, Steven Aitken, to reveal what private groups might have been involved in rewriting the Clinton-era order.
Aitken stressed that the Clinton order also used market failure as a criteria in advancing new rules and directing agencies to appoint regulatory policy officers, many of whom were political appointees. Rep. Dana Rohrabacher, R-Calif., backed Aitken up at the hearing.
"The pattern is that we are challenging the president's authority, hoping to find a mistake and then making a lot of political hay about it," Rohrabacher said.
The nonpartisan Congressional Research Service noted in an analysis last February that President Reagan made the White House regulatory affairs office the central clearinghouse for substantive rulemaking, reviewing 2,000 to 3,000 proposed regulations per year. With Clinton's 1993 order, White House reviews of proposed regulations dropped to between 500 and 700 a year, the researchers said.
Bill Kovacs, vice president for regulatory affairs with the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, said the White House's regulatory affairs office now has about 35 people to keep track of the 4,000 rules federal agencies issue every year.
"It's only reasonable that you have some way of monitoring what your agencies are doing," Kovacs said, adding that the White House needs to assert control over the process.
___
The House bill is HR 2829.
On the Net:
Text of Jan. 18 Executive Order 13422
Copyright 2007, The Associated Press. Read more
Monday, July 02, 2007
Comparative look at two ethics bills
By The Associated Press - Mon Jul 2, 2007
Similarities and differences in House and Senate lobbying bills that have to be merged into one before becoming law.
Both bills would:
_Require lobbyists to report when they "bundle" campaign contributions for one candidate from multiple donors.
_Forbid lawmakers from pressuring lobbying firms to hire employees based on political affiliations.
___
The Senate bill, but not the House bill, would:
_Require former lawmakers to wait two years, rather than one, before becoming lobbyists.
_Prohibit lobbyists from throwing parties for specific lawmakers at national conventions.
___
The House bill, but not the Senate bill, would:
_Require lobbyists who try to place "earmarks" — special home-state projects — in spending bills to identify their efforts.
_Require lobbyists to report bundled donations given to political action committees — or PACs — set up by unions, corporations or special interest groups, as well as to candidates.
___
The Senate bill is S 1.
The House bill is HR 2316
See Article
Ethics reform bogged down in Congress
By CHARLES BABINGTON, Associated Press Writer - Jul 2, 2007
WASHINGTON - Toughening ethics laws, once a priority of Democrats, has bogged down in Congress as party leaders find their campaign promises colliding with lawmakers' re-election concerns.
Two months have passed since a task force was supposed to have recommended how an independent panel might look into ethics complaints before they go to the House ethics committee. A key sticking point is opposition in both parties to letting outsiders file complaints against members of Congress.
Currently, only House members can initiate an ethics probe. Public watchdog groups call the restriction self-serving and unreasonable.
Some of the same groups, however, are balking at a second proposal floated by task force members. It would require any group that lodges an ethics complaint against a House member to reveal its donors.
Rep. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., said the demand for donor lists from groups that file complaints "is what has tied this thing up for now."
The nonprofit groups call it intimidation. Lawmakers say it's a way to ascertain whether such groups are backed by right- or left-leaning forces with partisan motives.
Meanwhile, a Senate spat over rules governing senators' requests for special projects in their home states is blocking efforts to merge into one bill separate House- and Senate-passed measures to restrict lawmakers' dealings with lobbyists. The Senate passed its version in January, and the House passed its bill in May.
"I find it distressing that they haven't dealt with these issues," Craig Holman of Public Citizen said, referring particularly to the House task force.
For years, self-described government-reform groups have denounced the House ethics committee, which is evenly divided between Democrats and Republicans, as listless and largely toothless. Unlike the Senate ethics committee, the House panel no longer accepts complaints from nonmembers. And it sometimes says little or nothing about its inquiries, leaving the public unsure whether serious investigations took place.
On Jan. 31, Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., appointed a bipartisan task force to recommend whether an independent panel of nonmembers should investigate ethics complaints and play a role in enforcing rules of conduct. That report was due May 1.
Long past the deadline, task force members privately briefed colleagues on a plan in which the speaker and minority leader would each appoint three members to a panel that would look at complaints — from members or nonmembers — and recommend whether the House ethics committee should pursue them. The independent panel's findings, in most cases, would eventually become public.
The proposal immediately drew fire from seemingly every direction. "They have problems inside and outside," said Meredith McGehee, policy director of the nonpartisan Campaign Legal Center.
Several House members said political adversaries could use an open-complaint system to file dozens of frivolous allegations and then cite them in campaign attack ads. The concern is understandable, McGehee said, but senators have long allowed nonmembers to file ethics allegations "and they're not in peril."
Watchdog groups called the plan weak, especially because the new panel would lack subpoena powers to compel testimony and demand documents. The panel "would have a free hand to recommend the dismissal of a complaint and would be greatly restricted in recommending anything else," lawmakers were told in a letter last week from groups including Democracy 21, the League of Women Voters, Public Citizen and the Campaign Legal Center.
They also objected to the donor-disclosure proposal, which they called unprecedented for the House, Senate, Justice Department, Federal Election Commission and other agencies that receive public allegations of official wrongdoing.
"Now they want your donor base," if a group tries to file an ethics complaint, said Sarah Dufendach, chief of legislative affairs for Common Cause, which on balance supports the House proposals. "It may chill some groups from actually filing," she said.
Many lawmakers are insisting on such disclosures, saying the public should know as much as possible about people behind allegations that could hurt a politician's career. Some Republicans particularly like the disclosure proposal because they believe groups such as Common Cause are heavily financed by Democrats and liberals.
Dufendach shrugged off the concern. "Whatever kind of information you give is going to be spun," she said.
Rep. Michael Capuano, D-Mass., the chairman of the House task force, said its tentative recommendation to consider ethics complaints from outside groups remains a sticking point.
"We've had some push-back" from House members and outsiders, he said in an interview last week. "We're plugging ahead. The goal is to get something meaningful that can pass."
Capuano added, however, that could not predict whether the task force can settle on a plan that would win House approval.
___
The Senate lobbying bill is S 1.
The House lobbying bill is HR 2316.
Read article
Similarities and differences in House and Senate lobbying bills that have to be merged into one before becoming law.
Both bills would:
_Require lobbyists to report when they "bundle" campaign contributions for one candidate from multiple donors.
_Forbid lawmakers from pressuring lobbying firms to hire employees based on political affiliations.
___
The Senate bill, but not the House bill, would:
_Require former lawmakers to wait two years, rather than one, before becoming lobbyists.
_Prohibit lobbyists from throwing parties for specific lawmakers at national conventions.
___
The House bill, but not the Senate bill, would:
_Require lobbyists who try to place "earmarks" — special home-state projects — in spending bills to identify their efforts.
_Require lobbyists to report bundled donations given to political action committees — or PACs — set up by unions, corporations or special interest groups, as well as to candidates.
___
The Senate bill is S 1.
The House bill is HR 2316
See Article
Ethics reform bogged down in Congress
By CHARLES BABINGTON, Associated Press Writer - Jul 2, 2007
WASHINGTON - Toughening ethics laws, once a priority of Democrats, has bogged down in Congress as party leaders find their campaign promises colliding with lawmakers' re-election concerns.
Two months have passed since a task force was supposed to have recommended how an independent panel might look into ethics complaints before they go to the House ethics committee. A key sticking point is opposition in both parties to letting outsiders file complaints against members of Congress.
Currently, only House members can initiate an ethics probe. Public watchdog groups call the restriction self-serving and unreasonable.
Some of the same groups, however, are balking at a second proposal floated by task force members. It would require any group that lodges an ethics complaint against a House member to reveal its donors.
Rep. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., said the demand for donor lists from groups that file complaints "is what has tied this thing up for now."
The nonprofit groups call it intimidation. Lawmakers say it's a way to ascertain whether such groups are backed by right- or left-leaning forces with partisan motives.
Meanwhile, a Senate spat over rules governing senators' requests for special projects in their home states is blocking efforts to merge into one bill separate House- and Senate-passed measures to restrict lawmakers' dealings with lobbyists. The Senate passed its version in January, and the House passed its bill in May.
"I find it distressing that they haven't dealt with these issues," Craig Holman of Public Citizen said, referring particularly to the House task force.
For years, self-described government-reform groups have denounced the House ethics committee, which is evenly divided between Democrats and Republicans, as listless and largely toothless. Unlike the Senate ethics committee, the House panel no longer accepts complaints from nonmembers. And it sometimes says little or nothing about its inquiries, leaving the public unsure whether serious investigations took place.
On Jan. 31, Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., appointed a bipartisan task force to recommend whether an independent panel of nonmembers should investigate ethics complaints and play a role in enforcing rules of conduct. That report was due May 1.
Long past the deadline, task force members privately briefed colleagues on a plan in which the speaker and minority leader would each appoint three members to a panel that would look at complaints — from members or nonmembers — and recommend whether the House ethics committee should pursue them. The independent panel's findings, in most cases, would eventually become public.
The proposal immediately drew fire from seemingly every direction. "They have problems inside and outside," said Meredith McGehee, policy director of the nonpartisan Campaign Legal Center.
Several House members said political adversaries could use an open-complaint system to file dozens of frivolous allegations and then cite them in campaign attack ads. The concern is understandable, McGehee said, but senators have long allowed nonmembers to file ethics allegations "and they're not in peril."
Watchdog groups called the plan weak, especially because the new panel would lack subpoena powers to compel testimony and demand documents. The panel "would have a free hand to recommend the dismissal of a complaint and would be greatly restricted in recommending anything else," lawmakers were told in a letter last week from groups including Democracy 21, the League of Women Voters, Public Citizen and the Campaign Legal Center.
They also objected to the donor-disclosure proposal, which they called unprecedented for the House, Senate, Justice Department, Federal Election Commission and other agencies that receive public allegations of official wrongdoing.
"Now they want your donor base," if a group tries to file an ethics complaint, said Sarah Dufendach, chief of legislative affairs for Common Cause, which on balance supports the House proposals. "It may chill some groups from actually filing," she said.
Many lawmakers are insisting on such disclosures, saying the public should know as much as possible about people behind allegations that could hurt a politician's career. Some Republicans particularly like the disclosure proposal because they believe groups such as Common Cause are heavily financed by Democrats and liberals.
Dufendach shrugged off the concern. "Whatever kind of information you give is going to be spun," she said.
Rep. Michael Capuano, D-Mass., the chairman of the House task force, said its tentative recommendation to consider ethics complaints from outside groups remains a sticking point.
"We've had some push-back" from House members and outsiders, he said in an interview last week. "We're plugging ahead. The goal is to get something meaningful that can pass."
Capuano added, however, that could not predict whether the task force can settle on a plan that would win House approval.
___
The Senate lobbying bill is S 1.
The House lobbying bill is HR 2316.
Read article
Saturday, June 30, 2007
Tarrant County officials seek to cut two tax rates
By AMAN BATHEJA - Star-Telegram staff writer - Sat, Jun. 30, 2007
Most Tarrant County commissioners say they want to cut taxes for both the county and the Tarrant County Hospital District for next year.
County Judge Glen Whitley and Commissioners Roy Brooks, Gary Fickes and J.D. Johnson signaled plans to reduce taxes more than last year, when commissioners cut the county rate by one-tenth of a cent and left unchanged the rate for the hospital district, which operates the JPS Health Network.
Commissioner Marti VanRavenswaay did not return a call seeking comment.
The county tax rate is now 27.15 cents per $100 of assessed value. The hospital district tax rate is 23.5397 cents.
"I will not vote for a budget that does not include a tax rate decrease for the county taxes or the hospital district," Fickes said. "I'm not sure if we'll get to a penny, but I'd like to see a penny [reduction] for both."
Brooks said he hopes to approve at least a half-cent cut in the county rate and up to a full cent off the hospital district rate.
"We're approaching this budget with an eye toward doing the most with the least and being able to give something back in terms of tax relief to the taxpayer," Brooks said.
Johnson said he expected rising property values to allow the county's budget to grow while still cutting taxes.
For the owner of a $100,000 home, the 1-cent drop would mean $10 off a county tax bill of $271.50 and $10 off a hospital district tax bill of $235.40.
Property owners would not necessarily pay less in taxes, however, because many have seen increases in their property values.
Commissioners said they also plan to look closely at the hospital district's budget for next year. At the commissioners' meeting Tuesday, Whitley took the unusual step of asking for the JPS board to meet with commissioners in July before JPS approves its budget.
"I would like to get a sense of their priorities," Whitley said.
In the past year, the hospital district has drawn increasing criticism for amassing a multimillion-dollar surplus while not expanding services for poor and uninsured patients.
"We just have a lot of questions what is going on out there," Johnson said. "Going through their budget in detail and looking at it the same time that the board looks at it would be a wise idea."
A call to Robert Earley, JPS' senior vice president of public affairs and advocacy, was not returned Friday.
See Fort Worth Star-Telegram
Most Tarrant County commissioners say they want to cut taxes for both the county and the Tarrant County Hospital District for next year.
County Judge Glen Whitley and Commissioners Roy Brooks, Gary Fickes and J.D. Johnson signaled plans to reduce taxes more than last year, when commissioners cut the county rate by one-tenth of a cent and left unchanged the rate for the hospital district, which operates the JPS Health Network.
Commissioner Marti VanRavenswaay did not return a call seeking comment.
The county tax rate is now 27.15 cents per $100 of assessed value. The hospital district tax rate is 23.5397 cents.
"I will not vote for a budget that does not include a tax rate decrease for the county taxes or the hospital district," Fickes said. "I'm not sure if we'll get to a penny, but I'd like to see a penny [reduction] for both."
Brooks said he hopes to approve at least a half-cent cut in the county rate and up to a full cent off the hospital district rate.
"We're approaching this budget with an eye toward doing the most with the least and being able to give something back in terms of tax relief to the taxpayer," Brooks said.
Johnson said he expected rising property values to allow the county's budget to grow while still cutting taxes.
For the owner of a $100,000 home, the 1-cent drop would mean $10 off a county tax bill of $271.50 and $10 off a hospital district tax bill of $235.40.
Property owners would not necessarily pay less in taxes, however, because many have seen increases in their property values.
Commissioners said they also plan to look closely at the hospital district's budget for next year. At the commissioners' meeting Tuesday, Whitley took the unusual step of asking for the JPS board to meet with commissioners in July before JPS approves its budget.
"I would like to get a sense of their priorities," Whitley said.
In the past year, the hospital district has drawn increasing criticism for amassing a multimillion-dollar surplus while not expanding services for poor and uninsured patients.
"We just have a lot of questions what is going on out there," Johnson said. "Going through their budget in detail and looking at it the same time that the board looks at it would be a wise idea."
A call to Robert Earley, JPS' senior vice president of public affairs and advocacy, was not returned Friday.
See Fort Worth Star-Telegram
Friday, June 29, 2007
Trinity toll road foes say 80,000 signed petition for November vote
By BRUCE TOMASO - The Dallas Morning News - June 29, 2007
Dallas voters will decide in November whether to scrap the Trinity River toll road, if referendum petitions submitted Friday by opponents of the road are certified as valid.
City Council member Angela Hunt said her group, TrinityVote, had gathered more than 80,000 signatures to stop the toll road, a key component of the Trinity River Corridor Project. If 48,000 of those signatures are certified by the city secretary as valid and belonging to registered voters living in Dallas, a measure will be placed on the November ballot.
That measure would prohibit the construction of any road inside the river levees that is more than four lanes wide, with a speed limit of more than 35 mph.
“Here you see before you a mandate from 80,000 people in Dallas who say they want a voice in the future of our Trinity River,” Ms. Hunt said at a City Hall news conference. Behind her stood more than 50 volunteers from TrinityVote, many of them wearing T-shirts that said, “Park or toll road? Let the voters decide.”
Striking a populist chord, Ms. Hunt alluded to the fact that the toll road is supported by many members of the city’s civic, business and political elite.
“There are some politicians who want to pave the Trinity,” she said. “But that option is no longer in their hands. As of today, the decision is in our hands, the hands of the voters, where it rightfully belongs.”
Ms. Hunt contends that the toll road should be scrapped because it will detract from the proposed downtown river park that many perceive as the centerpiece of the Trinity Project. She said that when Dallas voters approved $246 million in bonds for the Trinity project in 1998, many thought they were voting for a low-speed parkway, not a high-speed, multi-lane toll road.
Supporters of the road say it's needed to alleviate downtown congestion, and that removing it now from the plans could delay work on other aspects of the Trinity project, including the park and flood-control improvements
Dallas voters will decide in November whether to scrap the Trinity River toll road, if referendum petitions submitted Friday by opponents of the road are certified as valid.
City Council member Angela Hunt said her group, TrinityVote, had gathered more than 80,000 signatures to stop the toll road, a key component of the Trinity River Corridor Project. If 48,000 of those signatures are certified by the city secretary as valid and belonging to registered voters living in Dallas, a measure will be placed on the November ballot.
That measure would prohibit the construction of any road inside the river levees that is more than four lanes wide, with a speed limit of more than 35 mph.
“Here you see before you a mandate from 80,000 people in Dallas who say they want a voice in the future of our Trinity River,” Ms. Hunt said at a City Hall news conference. Behind her stood more than 50 volunteers from TrinityVote, many of them wearing T-shirts that said, “Park or toll road? Let the voters decide.”
Striking a populist chord, Ms. Hunt alluded to the fact that the toll road is supported by many members of the city’s civic, business and political elite.
“There are some politicians who want to pave the Trinity,” she said. “But that option is no longer in their hands. As of today, the decision is in our hands, the hands of the voters, where it rightfully belongs.”
Ms. Hunt contends that the toll road should be scrapped because it will detract from the proposed downtown river park that many perceive as the centerpiece of the Trinity Project. She said that when Dallas voters approved $246 million in bonds for the Trinity project in 1998, many thought they were voting for a low-speed parkway, not a high-speed, multi-lane toll road.
Supporters of the road say it's needed to alleviate downtown congestion, and that removing it now from the plans could delay work on other aspects of the Trinity project, including the park and flood-control improvements
Wednesday, June 27, 2007
5-4 Supreme Court Weakens Curbs on Pre-Election TV Ads
Ruling on McCain-Feingold Law Opens Door for Interest Groups in '08
By Robert Barnes - Washington Post Staff Writer - Tuesday, June 26, 2007
The Supreme Court yesterday substantially weakened restrictions on the kinds of television ads that corporations and unions can finance in the days before an election, providing special interest groups with the opportunity for a far more expansive role in the 2008 elections.
Read more
RESPONSE FROM MARTIN FROST
Election ad ruling: I told you so
By Martin Frost - June 26, 2007
I almost never crow about a prediction. But Monday’s U.S. Supreme Court decision on the McCain-Feingold campaign legislation passed by Congress is the exception. Damn it, I told you so.
During congressional consideration of this legislation in 2001 and 2002, I repeatedly told my House colleagues that this was a terrible bill that would have truly awful consequences when the Supreme Court got through with it.
I even tried to insert a nonseverability clause into the legislation, which would have provided that the whole legislative scheme would fail if any portion of it were declared unconstitutional.
Almost nobody would listen. Other than Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), who also tried to sound the alarm, virtually everyone in Congress turned a deaf ear to my prediction.
You see, my colleagues in the House and Senate did not want to offend the editorial pages of The New York Times and the Washington Post. They did not want to be painted as “anti-reform.”
Here is the crux of my argument made repeatedly to members of the House Democratic Caucus:
The legislation neutered our two major political parties by prohibiting them from raising soft money (large corporate, union and individual contributions) that could be used for issue ads during the closing weeks of a campaign.
At the same time, the legislation enacted a Rube Goldberg scheme that permitted corporations and unions to finance issue ads until 60 days before general elections, after which they were banned until the election.
It was my position (which proved to be 100 percent accurate on Monday) that the U.S. Supreme Court would strike down the ban on corporate and union issue advertising during the two months before an election as an unconstitutional intrusion on free speech.
Thus special interests would have a green light to attack federal candidates during the closing days of a campaign (as long as they avoided using the magic words “vote for” or “vote against”) and the two major political parties would be defenseless to come to the aid of their own incumbents from these attacks because they could no longer raise soft money (the exact type of money being used by outside groups to launch these attacks).
Political parties could use “hard money” for these type ads. But “hard money” is, by definition, raised in much smaller amounts and primarily used for other purposes by parties.
My colleagues ignored my prediction and simply said, “Our lawyers have told us this is legal and we are going to do it,” even though the Supreme Court throughout the 1970s and 1980s had handed down a series of opinions equating the right to spend money on politics with the right to free speech.
And so we now have the worst of all worlds – unlimited special interest spending on federal campaigns and political parties powerless to combat it.
I told you so.
Martin Frost, a Democrat, represented the Dallas-Fort Worth area from 1979 to 2005. He rose to caucus chairman and head of the DCCC. He is now an attorney with Polsinelli Shalton Flanigan Suelthaus PC in Washington and serves as president of America Votes, a grass-roots voter mobilization and education effort.
--
By Robert Barnes - Washington Post Staff Writer - Tuesday, June 26, 2007
The Supreme Court yesterday substantially weakened restrictions on the kinds of television ads that corporations and unions can finance in the days before an election, providing special interest groups with the opportunity for a far more expansive role in the 2008 elections.
Read more
RESPONSE FROM MARTIN FROST
Election ad ruling: I told you so
By Martin Frost - June 26, 2007
I almost never crow about a prediction. But Monday’s U.S. Supreme Court decision on the McCain-Feingold campaign legislation passed by Congress is the exception. Damn it, I told you so.
During congressional consideration of this legislation in 2001 and 2002, I repeatedly told my House colleagues that this was a terrible bill that would have truly awful consequences when the Supreme Court got through with it.
I even tried to insert a nonseverability clause into the legislation, which would have provided that the whole legislative scheme would fail if any portion of it were declared unconstitutional.
Almost nobody would listen. Other than Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), who also tried to sound the alarm, virtually everyone in Congress turned a deaf ear to my prediction.
You see, my colleagues in the House and Senate did not want to offend the editorial pages of The New York Times and the Washington Post. They did not want to be painted as “anti-reform.”
Here is the crux of my argument made repeatedly to members of the House Democratic Caucus:
The legislation neutered our two major political parties by prohibiting them from raising soft money (large corporate, union and individual contributions) that could be used for issue ads during the closing weeks of a campaign.
At the same time, the legislation enacted a Rube Goldberg scheme that permitted corporations and unions to finance issue ads until 60 days before general elections, after which they were banned until the election.
It was my position (which proved to be 100 percent accurate on Monday) that the U.S. Supreme Court would strike down the ban on corporate and union issue advertising during the two months before an election as an unconstitutional intrusion on free speech.
Thus special interests would have a green light to attack federal candidates during the closing days of a campaign (as long as they avoided using the magic words “vote for” or “vote against”) and the two major political parties would be defenseless to come to the aid of their own incumbents from these attacks because they could no longer raise soft money (the exact type of money being used by outside groups to launch these attacks).
Political parties could use “hard money” for these type ads. But “hard money” is, by definition, raised in much smaller amounts and primarily used for other purposes by parties.
My colleagues ignored my prediction and simply said, “Our lawyers have told us this is legal and we are going to do it,” even though the Supreme Court throughout the 1970s and 1980s had handed down a series of opinions equating the right to spend money on politics with the right to free speech.
And so we now have the worst of all worlds – unlimited special interest spending on federal campaigns and political parties powerless to combat it.
I told you so.
Martin Frost, a Democrat, represented the Dallas-Fort Worth area from 1979 to 2005. He rose to caucus chairman and head of the DCCC. He is now an attorney with Polsinelli Shalton Flanigan Suelthaus PC in Washington and serves as president of America Votes, a grass-roots voter mobilization and education effort.
--
Tuesday, June 26, 2007
Guilty Verdict in the Case Against Arthur Andersen
Verdict seen as fatal blow to firm
By TOM FOWLER - Copyright 2002 Houston Chronicle - June 19, 2002
"I think everyone understands the firm is dead," said Columbia University law professor John Coffee.
Surprisingly, the jurors said they didn't consider the company's extensive shredding of documents to be an important part of the case.
The nine-man, three-woman jury delivered the verdict at 10:25 a.m., more than five weeks after testimony began and after 72 hours of deliberations over 10 days.
Despite the prosecution's elaborate description of widespread document destruction, jurors told reporters it had been the effort of Andersen in-house lawyer Nancy Temple to remove her name from the draft of a memo that led them to convict the firm.
Jury foreman Oscar Criner described the Temple memo as a "smoking gun."
"You read it, you read the law in the charge, and it just stands out," Criner said.
The memo in question, created and revised several times in mid-October, was designed to document how Andersen handled a disagreement with Enron over using the word "non-recurring" to describe a loss.
In an Oct. 16 e-mail to lead Enron auditor David Duncan and others, Temple said her name should not be left on the final memo because " ... it increases the chances that I might be a witness, which I prefer to avoid." She also mentioned checking into other ways to " ... protect ourselves from potential Section 10A issues," referring to a provision in Securities and Exchange Commission auditing regulations.
Jurors said by changing the memo and mentioning the SEC issues, it was clear Temple's intent was to keep information away from investigators.
Discussing the verdict afterward, prosecutors said they were not initially aware that the memo was central to the verdict.
But when told what jurors had said to reporters about the Temple memo, they said the jury's finding was consistent with many aspects of their case.
"That memo was an important one that we referred to several times in our case," said Assistant U.S. Attorney Andrew Weissmann. "She made every effort to sanitize their files."
Jurors also said they all agreed Temple was the "corrupt agent" in the case, indicating that a ruling on Friday that the jurors did not have to agree on a single culprit was not as significant as previously thought.
Lead Andersen attorney Rusty Hardin praised the jury for its diligence but said the firm was a victim of "a system out of balance."
He criticized prosecutors for bringing the charges against Andersen and U.S. District Judge Melinda Harmon's rulings on a variety of issues.
"Our position as to whether Arthur Andersen committed a crime has not changed. They did not," he said.
The company plans to appeal after it is sentenced Oct. 11. Andersen officials said in a statement Saturday that the company expects to cease its audit practice by Aug. 31.
Andersen partner C.E. Andrews, who sat through much of the trial, said the company has no regrets about fighting the charge.
"We started with what was supposed to be an open-and-shut case and kept up the fight for our honor and dignity," Andrews said.
Andersen is already a shell of its former self. The firm has lost 690 of its 2,311 public company clients since Jan. 1. It has shrunk from 27,000 employees in the United States to no more than 10,000, a result of layoffs and departures of whole offices and practices to competing firms.
Prosecutors were cheered by the verdict, saying it will help them as they seek indictments against Enron and its executives.
Weissmann denied Andersen's accusations that the Justice Department destroyed the livelihood of 28,000 U.S. workers with the indictment, saying it was Andersen's management decisions that led to the trial, the verdict and the likely death of the accounting firm.
"No other audit firm in the nation has more problems with the SEC than Andersen," Weissmann said, referring to fines and warnings the firm received for its work with companies Waste Management and Sunbeam. "They chose to handle it this way and made martyrs out of their employees."
The case was initially thought to be an easy win for prosecutors, but Assistant U.S. Attorney Sam Buell said he never assumed it would be a slam-dunk case.
"We were prosecuting the largest, most resourceful defendant in the country that brought the most resources it could to bear," Buell said.
Indeed, up until a few days ago the lengthy jury deliberations had many assuming the trial would end with an acquittal or a deadlocked jury.
The jury did indicate that it was deadlocked at the end of day seven, on June 12, but was told by Harmon to keep trying.
...
Martin Bienenstock, an attorney for Enron, said he didn't want to pass judgment until the appellate process was completed, but he acknowledged he was surprised by the verdict.
"The verdict accentuates how so many innocent, hard-working people at Andersen and Enron have been hurt badly by the actions of a few people," said Bienenstock. "I was hoping the acts of at most a handful of people wouldn't destroy a fine institution."
Andersen was the auditor for Enron, the Houston-based energy trading giant that collapsed in a crisis of investor confidence late last year. Government investigators charge that Enron used complicated accounting schemes, many of which were sanctioned by Andersen, to report misleading financial results.
Enron officials have denied the charges.
Former Enron CEO Jeff Skilling had no comment, according to his wife, encountered pulling out of the family's River Oaks home driveway.
Kelly Kimberly, spokeswoman for former Enron Chairman Ken Lay, said Lay had no comment. And efforts to reach former chief financial officer Andrew Fastow were unsuccessful.
Neither side disputes the events in question behind the trial. They differ on how those events should be interpreted.
In October 2001, as the scope of the accounting problems for Andersen client Enron became clear, a number of Andersen employees in Houston and other offices destroyed documents related to their work with Enron.
The directive to destroy the documents was passed from Temple to the Enron team via e-mail, and later discussed in staff meetings and conference calls. It wasn't until the SEC subpoenaed Andersen on Nov. 8 that the document destruction stopped.
But what prosecutors called an organized effort to hide documents from the SEC was described by Andersen officials as an effort to catch up with long-overdue housekeeping motivated not by criminal intent but fear of reprisals from superiors at company headquarters in Chicago.
Before the trial began May 6, many observers said those differing views on the events would not -- and should not -- have led to a courtroom.
Andersen reported the shredding voluntarily in early January, and went so far as to fire lead Enron auditor Duncan, and put other top partners on administrative leave.
The company initially believed it could reach a settlement with SEC officials and investigators, a route followed by many corporations since major criminal cases against companies rarely make it to the courtroom.
But during February and March, attempts to settle never came together. Prosecutors saw Andersen's previous SEC problems, particularly its probationary status after accounting problems with client Waste Management, as too serious to ignore. Andersen wasn't willing to concede guilt in the case and kept insisting that a small group of Houston partners acting alone led to the document destruction.
An indictment against the entire firm for one count of obstruction of justice was unsealed March 14. Andersen clients began to flee the firm in droves and employees took to the streets to protest what they said would be the death of the 90-year-old firm.
There were other settlement efforts, and it was widely believed an eleventh-hour settlement would prevent the trial. But it never came.
"The Justice Department saw the prior record of Andersen and wanted blood, and Andersen didn't believe it had done wrong and didn't want to negotiate," said Art Bowman, author of a monthly accounting industry newsletter. "So they were both hard-headed and both fighting to the death. That's why it ended up in trial."
Prosecutors seemed to have the clear advantage going into the trial May 6, bolstered by a plea agreement with Duncan that had him admitting his guilt and agreeing to testify against Andersen in exchange for a chance at a lighter sentence.
... When Duncan finally began testimony on May 14, he appeared to deliver as promised for the prosecution. On cross-examination, however, his story appeared to wilt.
Hardin questioned him closely about his testimony that it wasn't until a couple of weeks before he signed the plea agreement that he really believed he was guilty. He suggested that it was fear of prison, not honest soul searching, that led Duncan to plead guilty.
The calm precision of many of Duncan's answers also came across as coached, particularly as Hardin asked him about whether he tried to keep information away from the SEC. Duncan repeatedly used the phrase that he "knew the documents that I destroyed would not be available for others to review," a statement that fell short of admitting a crime.
"We couldn't have paid David Duncan to be this good a witness," Hardin said when he finished testimony May 17.
Prosecutors came back with a vengeance the following week, however, introducing into evidence handwritten notes from Temple, which seemed to indicate that early in October 2001 she and others at the firm knew the SEC would be interested in Enron's accounting problems.
In notes from an Oct. 9 phone call with a handful of Andersen partners, Temple wrote, "Highly probable some SEC investigation," and that there was the " ... probability of charge of violating (cease and desist order agreed to after the firm was prosecuted for auditing violations involving Waste Management)."
The Temple notes, and many other pieces of evidence, had to be introduced by FBI agents simply reading them into record since Temple and two other witnesses refused to testify based on their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination.
The manner of presentation appeared to undermine the strength of the evidence, as indicated by comments from alternate juror Gloria Antia, who told the Chronicle she found it unseemly that the government spoke so badly about Temple without her being brought before the jury.
"I don't know if she refused to testify or if they didn't call her, but it seemed like they were talking behind her back," Antia said.
Just as Duncan proved beneficial to the defense, the defense's first witness on May 27 ended up benefiting the prosecution.
...
Andersen attorneys later tried to challenge key points in the indictment, such as the date the document destruction began and where it took place, through the testimony of several employees.
One former Andersen manager, Emily Madison, testified that she and a supervisor had e-mailed Andersen senior partner Michael Odom on Oct. 8 asking how the document-retention policy should apply toward a client that had just fired Andersen as its auditor.
The defense suggested that question may have been the motive for comments Odom made in a videotaped conference two days later, where he talked about how it was appropriate to destroy documents up until the day before litigation was filed against the firm.
Other Andersen employees testified that they didn't take the reminders about the policy to mean they should destroy documents, while Duncan's former administrative assistant, Shannon Adlong, said the Houston office was worried that their superiors in Chicago would see how far behind they had gotten in their regular document cleanup.
...
While Andersen is likely to be out of business before a full appeal can be heard, the company and its defense team is determined to go down fighting. The most immediate fight may be with state accounting regulatory agencies that will try to use the conviction to ban Andersen from doing audit work, a process the state of Texas has already begun.
"Everybody can jump in and pile on, and if an accounting board wants to, we say come on down," Hardin said. "We'll be there."
See full article, links to legal documents, Indictment, Andersen's ex-employees site, and timeline of Andersen event and Chronicle's archives of Andersen coverage
and Chronicle Archive of Enron coverage.
By TOM FOWLER - Copyright 2002 Houston Chronicle - June 19, 2002
"I think everyone understands the firm is dead," said Columbia University law professor John Coffee.
Surprisingly, the jurors said they didn't consider the company's extensive shredding of documents to be an important part of the case.
The nine-man, three-woman jury delivered the verdict at 10:25 a.m., more than five weeks after testimony began and after 72 hours of deliberations over 10 days.
Despite the prosecution's elaborate description of widespread document destruction, jurors told reporters it had been the effort of Andersen in-house lawyer Nancy Temple to remove her name from the draft of a memo that led them to convict the firm.
Jury foreman Oscar Criner described the Temple memo as a "smoking gun."
"You read it, you read the law in the charge, and it just stands out," Criner said.
The memo in question, created and revised several times in mid-October, was designed to document how Andersen handled a disagreement with Enron over using the word "non-recurring" to describe a loss.
In an Oct. 16 e-mail to lead Enron auditor David Duncan and others, Temple said her name should not be left on the final memo because " ... it increases the chances that I might be a witness, which I prefer to avoid." She also mentioned checking into other ways to " ... protect ourselves from potential Section 10A issues," referring to a provision in Securities and Exchange Commission auditing regulations.
Jurors said by changing the memo and mentioning the SEC issues, it was clear Temple's intent was to keep information away from investigators.
Discussing the verdict afterward, prosecutors said they were not initially aware that the memo was central to the verdict.
But when told what jurors had said to reporters about the Temple memo, they said the jury's finding was consistent with many aspects of their case.
"That memo was an important one that we referred to several times in our case," said Assistant U.S. Attorney Andrew Weissmann. "She made every effort to sanitize their files."
Jurors also said they all agreed Temple was the "corrupt agent" in the case, indicating that a ruling on Friday that the jurors did not have to agree on a single culprit was not as significant as previously thought.
Lead Andersen attorney Rusty Hardin praised the jury for its diligence but said the firm was a victim of "a system out of balance."
He criticized prosecutors for bringing the charges against Andersen and U.S. District Judge Melinda Harmon's rulings on a variety of issues.
"Our position as to whether Arthur Andersen committed a crime has not changed. They did not," he said.
The company plans to appeal after it is sentenced Oct. 11. Andersen officials said in a statement Saturday that the company expects to cease its audit practice by Aug. 31.
Andersen partner C.E. Andrews, who sat through much of the trial, said the company has no regrets about fighting the charge.
"We started with what was supposed to be an open-and-shut case and kept up the fight for our honor and dignity," Andrews said.
Andersen is already a shell of its former self. The firm has lost 690 of its 2,311 public company clients since Jan. 1. It has shrunk from 27,000 employees in the United States to no more than 10,000, a result of layoffs and departures of whole offices and practices to competing firms.
Prosecutors were cheered by the verdict, saying it will help them as they seek indictments against Enron and its executives.
Weissmann denied Andersen's accusations that the Justice Department destroyed the livelihood of 28,000 U.S. workers with the indictment, saying it was Andersen's management decisions that led to the trial, the verdict and the likely death of the accounting firm.
"No other audit firm in the nation has more problems with the SEC than Andersen," Weissmann said, referring to fines and warnings the firm received for its work with companies Waste Management and Sunbeam. "They chose to handle it this way and made martyrs out of their employees."
The case was initially thought to be an easy win for prosecutors, but Assistant U.S. Attorney Sam Buell said he never assumed it would be a slam-dunk case.
"We were prosecuting the largest, most resourceful defendant in the country that brought the most resources it could to bear," Buell said.
Indeed, up until a few days ago the lengthy jury deliberations had many assuming the trial would end with an acquittal or a deadlocked jury.
The jury did indicate that it was deadlocked at the end of day seven, on June 12, but was told by Harmon to keep trying.
...
Martin Bienenstock, an attorney for Enron, said he didn't want to pass judgment until the appellate process was completed, but he acknowledged he was surprised by the verdict.
"The verdict accentuates how so many innocent, hard-working people at Andersen and Enron have been hurt badly by the actions of a few people," said Bienenstock. "I was hoping the acts of at most a handful of people wouldn't destroy a fine institution."
Andersen was the auditor for Enron, the Houston-based energy trading giant that collapsed in a crisis of investor confidence late last year. Government investigators charge that Enron used complicated accounting schemes, many of which were sanctioned by Andersen, to report misleading financial results.
Enron officials have denied the charges.
Former Enron CEO Jeff Skilling had no comment, according to his wife, encountered pulling out of the family's River Oaks home driveway.
Kelly Kimberly, spokeswoman for former Enron Chairman Ken Lay, said Lay had no comment. And efforts to reach former chief financial officer Andrew Fastow were unsuccessful.
Neither side disputes the events in question behind the trial. They differ on how those events should be interpreted.
In October 2001, as the scope of the accounting problems for Andersen client Enron became clear, a number of Andersen employees in Houston and other offices destroyed documents related to their work with Enron.
The directive to destroy the documents was passed from Temple to the Enron team via e-mail, and later discussed in staff meetings and conference calls. It wasn't until the SEC subpoenaed Andersen on Nov. 8 that the document destruction stopped.
But what prosecutors called an organized effort to hide documents from the SEC was described by Andersen officials as an effort to catch up with long-overdue housekeeping motivated not by criminal intent but fear of reprisals from superiors at company headquarters in Chicago.
Before the trial began May 6, many observers said those differing views on the events would not -- and should not -- have led to a courtroom.
Andersen reported the shredding voluntarily in early January, and went so far as to fire lead Enron auditor Duncan, and put other top partners on administrative leave.
The company initially believed it could reach a settlement with SEC officials and investigators, a route followed by many corporations since major criminal cases against companies rarely make it to the courtroom.
But during February and March, attempts to settle never came together. Prosecutors saw Andersen's previous SEC problems, particularly its probationary status after accounting problems with client Waste Management, as too serious to ignore. Andersen wasn't willing to concede guilt in the case and kept insisting that a small group of Houston partners acting alone led to the document destruction.
An indictment against the entire firm for one count of obstruction of justice was unsealed March 14. Andersen clients began to flee the firm in droves and employees took to the streets to protest what they said would be the death of the 90-year-old firm.
There were other settlement efforts, and it was widely believed an eleventh-hour settlement would prevent the trial. But it never came.
"The Justice Department saw the prior record of Andersen and wanted blood, and Andersen didn't believe it had done wrong and didn't want to negotiate," said Art Bowman, author of a monthly accounting industry newsletter. "So they were both hard-headed and both fighting to the death. That's why it ended up in trial."
Prosecutors seemed to have the clear advantage going into the trial May 6, bolstered by a plea agreement with Duncan that had him admitting his guilt and agreeing to testify against Andersen in exchange for a chance at a lighter sentence.
... When Duncan finally began testimony on May 14, he appeared to deliver as promised for the prosecution. On cross-examination, however, his story appeared to wilt.
Hardin questioned him closely about his testimony that it wasn't until a couple of weeks before he signed the plea agreement that he really believed he was guilty. He suggested that it was fear of prison, not honest soul searching, that led Duncan to plead guilty.
The calm precision of many of Duncan's answers also came across as coached, particularly as Hardin asked him about whether he tried to keep information away from the SEC. Duncan repeatedly used the phrase that he "knew the documents that I destroyed would not be available for others to review," a statement that fell short of admitting a crime.
"We couldn't have paid David Duncan to be this good a witness," Hardin said when he finished testimony May 17.
Prosecutors came back with a vengeance the following week, however, introducing into evidence handwritten notes from Temple, which seemed to indicate that early in October 2001 she and others at the firm knew the SEC would be interested in Enron's accounting problems.
In notes from an Oct. 9 phone call with a handful of Andersen partners, Temple wrote, "Highly probable some SEC investigation," and that there was the " ... probability of charge of violating (cease and desist order agreed to after the firm was prosecuted for auditing violations involving Waste Management)."
The Temple notes, and many other pieces of evidence, had to be introduced by FBI agents simply reading them into record since Temple and two other witnesses refused to testify based on their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination.
The manner of presentation appeared to undermine the strength of the evidence, as indicated by comments from alternate juror Gloria Antia, who told the Chronicle she found it unseemly that the government spoke so badly about Temple without her being brought before the jury.
"I don't know if she refused to testify or if they didn't call her, but it seemed like they were talking behind her back," Antia said.
Just as Duncan proved beneficial to the defense, the defense's first witness on May 27 ended up benefiting the prosecution.
...
Andersen attorneys later tried to challenge key points in the indictment, such as the date the document destruction began and where it took place, through the testimony of several employees.
One former Andersen manager, Emily Madison, testified that she and a supervisor had e-mailed Andersen senior partner Michael Odom on Oct. 8 asking how the document-retention policy should apply toward a client that had just fired Andersen as its auditor.
The defense suggested that question may have been the motive for comments Odom made in a videotaped conference two days later, where he talked about how it was appropriate to destroy documents up until the day before litigation was filed against the firm.
Other Andersen employees testified that they didn't take the reminders about the policy to mean they should destroy documents, while Duncan's former administrative assistant, Shannon Adlong, said the Houston office was worried that their superiors in Chicago would see how far behind they had gotten in their regular document cleanup.
...
While Andersen is likely to be out of business before a full appeal can be heard, the company and its defense team is determined to go down fighting. The most immediate fight may be with state accounting regulatory agencies that will try to use the conviction to ban Andersen from doing audit work, a process the state of Texas has already begun.
"Everybody can jump in and pile on, and if an accounting board wants to, we say come on down," Hardin said. "We'll be there."
See full article, links to legal documents, Indictment, Andersen's ex-employees site, and timeline of Andersen event and Chronicle's archives of Andersen coverage
and Chronicle Archive of Enron coverage.
U-S marshal admits selling govt information
© 2007 The Associated Press - June 26, 2007
McALLEN, Texas — A South Texas lawman faces up to five years in federal prison after admitting he sold government information.
Sentencing is October ninth for U.S. Marshal Jose Magallan, who was assigned to the McAllen office.
A federal judge in Houston yesterday accepted the guilty plea involving two counts of Magallan exceeding his authorized access to information in a computer.
Prosecutors say Magallan last November and in January accepted money to do an unauthorized computer search for a private citizen and then deliver the information.
The 52-year-old deputy overall received -- 950 dollars.
The former McAllen policeman faces fines of up to $250,000 for each count.
Houston Chronicle
McALLEN, Texas — A South Texas lawman faces up to five years in federal prison after admitting he sold government information.
Sentencing is October ninth for U.S. Marshal Jose Magallan, who was assigned to the McAllen office.
A federal judge in Houston yesterday accepted the guilty plea involving two counts of Magallan exceeding his authorized access to information in a computer.
Prosecutors say Magallan last November and in January accepted money to do an unauthorized computer search for a private citizen and then deliver the information.
The 52-year-old deputy overall received -- 950 dollars.
The former McAllen policeman faces fines of up to $250,000 for each count.
Houston Chronicle
Labels:
corruption,
Jose Magallan,
McAllen,
US Marshal
ON POLITICS - Greeting the season by closing loopholes
By KRISTEN MACK - Copyright 2005 Houston Chronicle - Jan. 27, 2005
With this year's city campaign season looming, City Council closed — or at least narrowed — a loophole that some believed gave certain candidates a head start in campaign funding.
[Houston] Council this week put a $10,000 cap on the amount that people who hold non-city elective offices can transfer from campaign coffers for those offices to fund city races.
Candidates in November's [Houston] city election cannot begin raising money until Tuesday. Council set the cap out of concern that non-city elected officials who have raised money previously for those offices could transfer unlimited funds into city campaign accounts.
Councilman Gordon Quan, who chairs council's ethics committee, said the changes specifically were prompted by the candidacies of Herman Litt, who is running for District C, and Jay Aiyer, who is running in at-large Position 2. Both are Houston Community College System trustees.
Aiyer held a fund-raiser this fall for his HCC seat, and at least one of his council opponents complained that he would use the money for his council run.
Under the new rules, Quan said, committed contributors can always write checks for the city races.
"It's more honest that way," he said. "Give it to them for what they are running for, rather than false pretenses."
Aiyer said he doesn't believe the change targeted him.
"It is not a problem for me," he said. "Folks that contributed in the past, I assume will be contributors in the future."
Whatever their funding sources, candidates already are declaring for four seats that term-limited members council members will have to vacate at the end of this year.
And a fifth seat may open up if M.J. Khan, first-term councilman in District F, runs for the at-large Position 2. His political consultant, Spencer Neumann, expects Khan will announce this spring that he will be running for the citywide seat.
Some council members see at-large positions as more alluring because they allow them to focus on higher-profile citywide issues instead of con-
stituent-based concerns.
Council members who jump from district to at-large seats still are subject to the city's three-term limit.
Quan, a Chinese-American who is term-limited in Position 2, said he is concerned that Khan and Aiyer, both South Asians, will split the Asian vote.
But Aiyer said the growing Asian community still isn't big enough to swing an election anyway.
Houston Independent School District Trustee Kevin Hoffman, who was eyeing the Position 2 and District B seats, has decided not to run.
Architect Peter Brown is trying to position himself as the front-runner for at-large Position 1, being vacated by term-limited Councilman Mark Ellis. Brown, a Democrat and urban planning advocate who also ran for council in 2003, officially declared in May that he would run again.
Earlier this month Brown began circulating a letter asking people to join his campaign effort. The letter was signed by state Sen. Rodney Ellis, D-Houston, real estate developer Ed Wulfe, attorney Michael Solar and engineer Terry Cheng — covering several ethnic and political bases.
Businessman Jeff Daily, Brown's ideological opposite and also a 2003 City Council candidate, said he still is mulling whether to run for Position 1.
Attorney and former University of Houston track star Jolanda Jones, who along with Brown challenged Councilwoman Shelley Sekula-Gibbs in 2003, has said she also intends to run again, probably for Position 1.
Jones was a contestant on the CBS reality show Survivor, which airs beginning Feb. 17. A confidentiality agreement prohibits her from revealing whether she won the $1 million jackpot when the show taped last year.
If she did, it might help her survive an expensive council race.
With this year's city campaign season looming, City Council closed — or at least narrowed — a loophole that some believed gave certain candidates a head start in campaign funding.
[Houston] Council this week put a $10,000 cap on the amount that people who hold non-city elective offices can transfer from campaign coffers for those offices to fund city races.
Candidates in November's [Houston] city election cannot begin raising money until Tuesday. Council set the cap out of concern that non-city elected officials who have raised money previously for those offices could transfer unlimited funds into city campaign accounts.
Councilman Gordon Quan, who chairs council's ethics committee, said the changes specifically were prompted by the candidacies of Herman Litt, who is running for District C, and Jay Aiyer, who is running in at-large Position 2. Both are Houston Community College System trustees.
Aiyer held a fund-raiser this fall for his HCC seat, and at least one of his council opponents complained that he would use the money for his council run.
Under the new rules, Quan said, committed contributors can always write checks for the city races.
"It's more honest that way," he said. "Give it to them for what they are running for, rather than false pretenses."
Aiyer said he doesn't believe the change targeted him.
"It is not a problem for me," he said. "Folks that contributed in the past, I assume will be contributors in the future."
Whatever their funding sources, candidates already are declaring for four seats that term-limited members council members will have to vacate at the end of this year.
And a fifth seat may open up if M.J. Khan, first-term councilman in District F, runs for the at-large Position 2. His political consultant, Spencer Neumann, expects Khan will announce this spring that he will be running for the citywide seat.
Some council members see at-large positions as more alluring because they allow them to focus on higher-profile citywide issues instead of con-
stituent-based concerns.
Council members who jump from district to at-large seats still are subject to the city's three-term limit.
Quan, a Chinese-American who is term-limited in Position 2, said he is concerned that Khan and Aiyer, both South Asians, will split the Asian vote.
But Aiyer said the growing Asian community still isn't big enough to swing an election anyway.
Houston Independent School District Trustee Kevin Hoffman, who was eyeing the Position 2 and District B seats, has decided not to run.
Architect Peter Brown is trying to position himself as the front-runner for at-large Position 1, being vacated by term-limited Councilman Mark Ellis. Brown, a Democrat and urban planning advocate who also ran for council in 2003, officially declared in May that he would run again.
Earlier this month Brown began circulating a letter asking people to join his campaign effort. The letter was signed by state Sen. Rodney Ellis, D-Houston, real estate developer Ed Wulfe, attorney Michael Solar and engineer Terry Cheng — covering several ethnic and political bases.
Businessman Jeff Daily, Brown's ideological opposite and also a 2003 City Council candidate, said he still is mulling whether to run for Position 1.
Attorney and former University of Houston track star Jolanda Jones, who along with Brown challenged Councilwoman Shelley Sekula-Gibbs in 2003, has said she also intends to run again, probably for Position 1.
Jones was a contestant on the CBS reality show Survivor, which airs beginning Feb. 17. A confidentiality agreement prohibits her from revealing whether she won the $1 million jackpot when the show taped last year.
If she did, it might help her survive an expensive council race.
Labels:
$10,
000 cap,
Alyer,
campaign finance,
City Council,
HCC Trustee,
Houston
HCC Trustee Aiyer charged with felony - accused of tampering with campaign finance report
By KRISTEN MACK - Copyright 2007 Houston Chronicle - June 26, 2007
Houston Community College Trustee and one-time City Council candidate Jay Aiyer is facing a charge of tampering with a governmental record, a felony that could cost him his law license, authorities said Monday.
The Harris County District Attorney's Office accused Aiyer of committing the offense in March 2005, by "unlawfully removing, destroying, and concealing, the original filing" of a portion of his campaign finance report and substituting it with another document.
The charges were filed in the 184th criminal court last Thursday. Aiyer posted a $2,000 bond the following day.
Aiyer, reached Monday, said he could not talk about the charges in detail.
"We will be able to work this thing out in a couple of days," he said. "I think it's going to be resolved."
Aiyer, 38, a lawyer who once served as chief of staff to former Mayor Lee Brown, has hired Dennis Cain to represent him. Cain did not return a call seeking comment.
The charges stem from a complaint initially filed with the Texas Ethics Commission more than two years ago. The complaint, lodged by an associate of Aiyer's then-competitor and now City Councilwoman Sue Lovell, accused Aiyer of trying to hide expenditures from his HCC campaign account, including a loan repayment to himself of $5,000, when there was no record of the original loan. It also accused him of failing to report payments to political consultants and failing to itemize credit card payments.
The ethics commission referred the complaint to the Harris County district attorney's office in April 2006. The DA's office looked into whether Aiyer tampered with government records, but did not investigate potential election code violations, said Donna Goode, the division chief over the DA's public integrity unit.
When Aiyer became aware of the allegations, he met with HCC officials, who keep campaign finance filings. Over a period of a few months he reviewed his reports, according to the affidavit from the DA's office. Officials said it was during that time documents appear to have been switched.
On one occasion, Aiyer arrived with papers in his hand and was left unsupervised. During another visit, Aiyer asked to see a copy of public information requests filed for copies of his reports. He was provided one copy of a report by the legal assistant to the HCC general counsel and never returned with the file. On a third trip to the general counsel's office, Aiyer reportedly asked for a staple remover and stapler.
The DA's office also said different fonts appeared on paperwork Aiyer said he retyped and filed on a typewriter at HCC.
"The allegation is he obtained these records and destroyed or removed them with the intent to defraud to harm," Goode said.
Chronicle reporter Robert Crowe contributed to this report.
Read more
NOTE: This story is a follow-up to an earlier story by Kirsten Mack
HCCS account at root of candidate scrutiny
By KRISTEN MACK - Copyright 2005 Houston Chronicle - Aug. 4, 2005
The race is for the City Council, but campaign-finance reports under scrutiny are for the Houston Community College System.
Two candidates for Council At-Large Position 2 are studying the reports hoping to find an issue against a third candidate, HCCS board member Jay Aiyer. Aiyer says there's nothing to find.
Candidate Sue Lovell says the reports show that Aiyer has attempted to hide expenditures out of his HCCS campaign account — including a loan repayment to himself, unreported payments to political consultants and unitemized credit-card payments.
Aiyer was appointed to fill a vacancy on the college system board of trustees in 2001 and was elected to a six-year term later that year without opposition. Though his spot isn't up again until 2007, he has kept a campaign war chest.
Monitoring expenditures
Under a city law passed just this year, Aiyer can transfer no more than $10,000 from that account to his city race. But that potential head start has Lovell and another opponent, John Elford, scrutinizing Aiyer's reports.
Lovell produced Aiyer campaign-finance reports from 2004 listing a $5,000 disbursement to Aiyer and recording that it was to repay a loan he had made to his campaign.
Kathryn McNiel, who was Aiyer's political consultant in 2004 and completed the HCC campaign forms on his behalf, said she remembers seeing a $5,000 check to Aiyer and listing it among the campaign's reported expenditures.
The $5,000 payment doesn't show up on Aiyer campaign-finance reports provided to the Houston Chronicle by HCC's general counsel office, which keeps reports filed by board candidates.
Neither those documents nor the ones Lovell has record a loan from Aiyer to his campaign.
Many of the documents on file now are affidavits of correction that Aiyer filed in April.
Aiyer maintains his corrections weren't substantive and brushes off Lovell's complaints as "classic political stuff" designed to cast a cloud on his campaign.
Lovell says her complaints have nothing to do with politics.
"Campaign-finance reports tell a lot about the integrity of a person," she said. "Where you get your money and how you manage your money tell a lot about how you will manage taxpayer money when you're on council."
Filing ethics complaint
Allen Blakemore, political consultant to Aiyer's other announced opponent, John Elford, said he also has noticed discrepancies in Aiyer's reports.
"Jay Aiyer is not complying with the letter or spirit of the law," Blakemore said. "They are hiding things and playing fast and loose with the rules."
Kevin Roach, a friend of Lovell, filed a complaint with the Texas Ethics Commission in April alleging Aiyer converted campaign funds to personal use, failed to report political expenditures, failed to report the "payee and purpose" of certain expenditures and failed to itemize payments to credit-card companies.
Ethics complaints are confidential, unless the commission issues an "agreed order," meaning it has investigated allegations and found evidence of a violation.
All of this, remember, is over campaign-finance reports that don't involve the Position 2 race. Lovell also has perused Aiyer's City Council campaign-finance reports and says she sees no problems there.
That doesn't mean you won't hear more talk about campaign-finance issues as the council race gets hotter.
Read story
Houston Community College Trustee and one-time City Council candidate Jay Aiyer is facing a charge of tampering with a governmental record, a felony that could cost him his law license, authorities said Monday.
The Harris County District Attorney's Office accused Aiyer of committing the offense in March 2005, by "unlawfully removing, destroying, and concealing, the original filing" of a portion of his campaign finance report and substituting it with another document.
The charges were filed in the 184th criminal court last Thursday. Aiyer posted a $2,000 bond the following day.
Aiyer, reached Monday, said he could not talk about the charges in detail.
"We will be able to work this thing out in a couple of days," he said. "I think it's going to be resolved."
Aiyer, 38, a lawyer who once served as chief of staff to former Mayor Lee Brown, has hired Dennis Cain to represent him. Cain did not return a call seeking comment.
The charges stem from a complaint initially filed with the Texas Ethics Commission more than two years ago. The complaint, lodged by an associate of Aiyer's then-competitor and now City Councilwoman Sue Lovell, accused Aiyer of trying to hide expenditures from his HCC campaign account, including a loan repayment to himself of $5,000, when there was no record of the original loan. It also accused him of failing to report payments to political consultants and failing to itemize credit card payments.
The ethics commission referred the complaint to the Harris County district attorney's office in April 2006. The DA's office looked into whether Aiyer tampered with government records, but did not investigate potential election code violations, said Donna Goode, the division chief over the DA's public integrity unit.
When Aiyer became aware of the allegations, he met with HCC officials, who keep campaign finance filings. Over a period of a few months he reviewed his reports, according to the affidavit from the DA's office. Officials said it was during that time documents appear to have been switched.
On one occasion, Aiyer arrived with papers in his hand and was left unsupervised. During another visit, Aiyer asked to see a copy of public information requests filed for copies of his reports. He was provided one copy of a report by the legal assistant to the HCC general counsel and never returned with the file. On a third trip to the general counsel's office, Aiyer reportedly asked for a staple remover and stapler.
The DA's office also said different fonts appeared on paperwork Aiyer said he retyped and filed on a typewriter at HCC.
"The allegation is he obtained these records and destroyed or removed them with the intent to defraud to harm," Goode said.
"A state jail felony is pretty serious for anybody. When you add on top of that that he is a licensed attorney and he is in an elected position, it's a very serious concern."
Chronicle reporter Robert Crowe contributed to this report.
Read more
NOTE: This story is a follow-up to an earlier story by Kirsten Mack
By KRISTEN MACK - Copyright 2005 Houston Chronicle - Aug. 4, 2005
The race is for the City Council, but campaign-finance reports under scrutiny are for the Houston Community College System.
Two candidates for Council At-Large Position 2 are studying the reports hoping to find an issue against a third candidate, HCCS board member Jay Aiyer. Aiyer says there's nothing to find.
Candidate Sue Lovell says the reports show that Aiyer has attempted to hide expenditures out of his HCCS campaign account — including a loan repayment to himself, unreported payments to political consultants and unitemized credit-card payments.
"Anyone can file a complaint and allege that someone did something wrong," responded Aiyer. "In my case, it's not true. Her allegations are all factually incorrect."
Aiyer was appointed to fill a vacancy on the college system board of trustees in 2001 and was elected to a six-year term later that year without opposition. Though his spot isn't up again until 2007, he has kept a campaign war chest.
Monitoring expenditures
Under a city law passed just this year, Aiyer can transfer no more than $10,000 from that account to his city race. But that potential head start has Lovell and another opponent, John Elford, scrutinizing Aiyer's reports.
Lovell produced Aiyer campaign-finance reports from 2004 listing a $5,000 disbursement to Aiyer and recording that it was to repay a loan he had made to his campaign.
Kathryn McNiel, who was Aiyer's political consultant in 2004 and completed the HCC campaign forms on his behalf, said she remembers seeing a $5,000 check to Aiyer and listing it among the campaign's reported expenditures.
"Once those reports left my hands, I do not know what changes Jay made to them, when he finalized them,"McNiel said.
The $5,000 payment doesn't show up on Aiyer campaign-finance reports provided to the Houston Chronicle by HCC's general counsel office, which keeps reports filed by board candidates.
Neither those documents nor the ones Lovell has record a loan from Aiyer to his campaign.
Many of the documents on file now are affidavits of correction that Aiyer filed in April.
Aiyer maintains his corrections weren't substantive and brushes off Lovell's complaints as "classic political stuff" designed to cast a cloud on his campaign.
Lovell says her complaints have nothing to do with politics.
"Campaign-finance reports tell a lot about the integrity of a person," she said. "Where you get your money and how you manage your money tell a lot about how you will manage taxpayer money when you're on council."
Filing ethics complaint
Allen Blakemore, political consultant to Aiyer's other announced opponent, John Elford, said he also has noticed discrepancies in Aiyer's reports.
"Jay Aiyer is not complying with the letter or spirit of the law," Blakemore said. "They are hiding things and playing fast and loose with the rules."
Kevin Roach, a friend of Lovell, filed a complaint with the Texas Ethics Commission in April alleging Aiyer converted campaign funds to personal use, failed to report political expenditures, failed to report the "payee and purpose" of certain expenditures and failed to itemize payments to credit-card companies.
Ethics complaints are confidential, unless the commission issues an "agreed order," meaning it has investigated allegations and found evidence of a violation.
All of this, remember, is over campaign-finance reports that don't involve the Position 2 race. Lovell also has perused Aiyer's City Council campaign-finance reports and says she sees no problems there.
That doesn't mean you won't hear more talk about campaign-finance issues as the council race gets hotter.
Read story
Federal bribery probe grips El Paso
Investigation links several city leaders to corruption, multiple plotsBy GARY SCHARRER - Copyright 2007 Houston Chronicle Austin Bureau
EL PASO — Alleged bribery payoffs plotted in a bathroom stall. A truckload of county records hauled off by FBI agents. A guilty plea that alleges routine corruption by a web of current and former officials.
This city of 735,000 has been riveted by a federal bribery investigation targeting a chain of suspects, including a former White House appointee.
"It's the Manhattan Project for the El Paso FBI," said one federal agent working the case, referring to the mammoth 1940s effort to develop the atomic bomb.
So far, the former chief of staff for El Paso County Judge Anthony Cobos has pleaded guilty to four counts of conspiracy and fraud, admitting his involvement in alleged payoffs for county contracts.
In his plea document, John Travis Ketner described 17 unnamed co-conspirators in ways that make them easily recognizable to observers of El Paso politics — so recognizable that the principals have not denied that he identified them.
They include Cobos, El Paso County Commissioners Miguel Teran and Luis Sarinana — whose offices and the homes of other civic leaders were raided by 75 federal agents last month — and Luther Jones, a former state representative described as "Co-conspirator One."
Ketner also described Arturo Duran, who was President Bush's former appointee to the International Boundary and Water Commission, as the "bag man" for several alleged bribery schemes.
All have denied wrongdoing.
Contracts in question
Speculation among some community leaders is that the two-year investigation could result in the indictment of 50 people, a number a federal agent called "not unreasonable."
Adding to the intrigue is an acknowledgment from current El Paso County Commissioner Dan Haggerty that he had met secretly with FBI agents for nearly two years.
Haggerty has long been suspicious that county contracts for goods, services and construction were rigged.
"Some of the people I have worked with on Commissioner's Court are really stupid," said Haggerty, brother of longtime state Rep. Pat Haggerty, R-El Paso. "They thought they could do whatever they were doing that was totally corrupt, not knowing that it was totally corrupt.
"If this is OK, why are we meeting in this stall in the bathroom on the basement floor of the courthouse?" Haggerty said. "Why does it smell in here?"
Ketner's pleading described a courthouse restroom meeting between Cobos (described as "Co-conspirator Five") and Duran ("Co-conspirator Seven") involving a promise of money from Duran for contracts benefiting Duran's clients.The document charges that county contracts were selected based on "who offered ... the greatest amount of remuneration in money or other benefits."
Duran and Cobos have denied the allegations.
Placing blame
Duran served on the boundary commission until a scathing report by the State Department's inspector general two years ago forced his resignation. The report blamed Duran for creating internal management problems that engulfed the agency, "threatening its essential responsibilities for flood control and water management in the American Southwest."
After Ketner's plea became public, an indignant El Pasoan, Lisa Turner, showed up at the next commissioners court meeting to urge Cobos, Teran and Sarinana to resign.
Replying for the embattled three, Cobos blamed unnamed local power brokers for the legal storm.
"When you go against the status quo, you better be ready, because that's what I have done," Cobos said. "There are many people in this community with so much money and so much power. If I rubber-stamped what they wanted to do, this never would have happened."
Expanding investigation
After the FBI searched his office, Cobos told local reporters the agents could have simply requested documents and suggested the raid might be a "political blunt instrument to tarnish reputations."
He didn't appear any more rattled after his former chief of staff accused him.
Ketner's allegations did not trouble him, Cobos said, "because I know the truth. Obviously, they are encouraging him to get creative."
The FBI and the U.S. Attorney's Office have not commented except for terse news releases after the searches and after Ketner's guilty plea.
"We have been very tight-lipped about this investigation," acknowledged El Paso FBI spokeswoman Andrea Simmons. "It's an ongoing investigation, so it's not at a stage where we can give any details."
The probe initially focused on the alleged improper use of federal funds at a nonprofit called the National Center for Employment of the Disabled, since renamed ReadyOne. It has expanded to the county courthouse and is expected to reach El Paso school districts. The FBI also has requested documents from a prior City Hall administration, two current City Council members said.
Far-reaching probe
The FBI executed search warrants of 22 El Paso residences or businesses and wiretapped phones for nearly a year, an unusually long time, according to a former federal prosecutor.
"It tells me that the investigation is very far-reaching," said San Antonio lawyer Ron Ederer, a former U.S. attorney for the Western District of Texas under President George H.W. Bush. The probe is based on allegations of wrongdoing, not politics, Ederer said.
The investigation is "the subject of conversation everywhere," said longtime El Paso attorney Tom Diamond, who has served several terms as chairman of the El Paso Democratic Party.
"Out here, we're a little bit desensitized to the mordida (bribes). We have it right across the border. It's something that you don't consider because it's so prevalent in Mexico. I think it kind of bleeds over into our society," he said.
But that's changing, said Ederer, who practiced law in El Paso for 18 years before becoming a U.S. attorney.
"The city is no longer a little border town," he said. "It's growing by leaps and bounds and, as a result of that, law enforcement is becoming more sophisticated."
And industry expanding to border communities won't tolerate backroom deals, he said.
The probe, especially its gigantic scale, has angered some El Pasoans.
"We're shaking our heads. It's terrible. There is shock and outrage throughout the county," said Don Kirkpatrick, a Democratic Party activist. "What we have is a huge interlocking scandal, and at the center of it is Luther Jones."
'Cloud of gossip'
Jones, 60, served four terms in the Texas House in the 1970s. He later became El Paso county attorney and then county judge. For most of the past two decades, Jones has helped elect members to school boards, the City Council and county Commissioners Court, and he helped Ketner get his chief-of-staff job with Cobos.
Critics contend his influence has helped him secure contracts for friends.
"The city is just consumed in a cloud of gossip and rumors," Jones said in a recent interview. "My name is mentioned all the time, everything from being someone who's going to be dragged off in shackles to someone who's actively working behind the scenes with law enforcement people."
FBI agents searched Jones' home last fall.
Jones said he's not worried but acknowledges that "when lay people see your name in the papers associated with anything that has the word 'FBI' in front of it, automatically it conjures up notions that not only are you a criminal, but you're a seriously dangerous criminal."
Seeking a change
The allegations by Ketner "are all beneath contempt and unworthy of any response except categorical denial," Jones said.
The county commissioners whose offices were searched also deny any wrongdoing.
"I am not concerned. I never solicited nor have I ever accepted a bribe or money in exchange for any decision in the court," Teran said.
"I sleep comfortable at night," Sarinana said.
Whatever happens, some young El Paso political leaders are calling for a sea change in local politics.
"If good people are willing to step in and take leadership roles, then good things will happen," said Susie Byrd, a member of the El Paso City Council. "It won't happen on its own."
Read more
EL PASO — Alleged bribery payoffs plotted in a bathroom stall. A truckload of county records hauled off by FBI agents. A guilty plea that alleges routine corruption by a web of current and former officials.
This city of 735,000 has been riveted by a federal bribery investigation targeting a chain of suspects, including a former White House appointee.
"It's the Manhattan Project for the El Paso FBI," said one federal agent working the case, referring to the mammoth 1940s effort to develop the atomic bomb.
So far, the former chief of staff for El Paso County Judge Anthony Cobos has pleaded guilty to four counts of conspiracy and fraud, admitting his involvement in alleged payoffs for county contracts.
In his plea document, John Travis Ketner described 17 unnamed co-conspirators in ways that make them easily recognizable to observers of El Paso politics — so recognizable that the principals have not denied that he identified them.
They include Cobos, El Paso County Commissioners Miguel Teran and Luis Sarinana — whose offices and the homes of other civic leaders were raided by 75 federal agents last month — and Luther Jones, a former state representative described as "Co-conspirator One."
Ketner also described Arturo Duran, who was President Bush's former appointee to the International Boundary and Water Commission, as the "bag man" for several alleged bribery schemes.
All have denied wrongdoing.
Contracts in question
Speculation among some community leaders is that the two-year investigation could result in the indictment of 50 people, a number a federal agent called "not unreasonable."
Adding to the intrigue is an acknowledgment from current El Paso County Commissioner Dan Haggerty that he had met secretly with FBI agents for nearly two years.
Haggerty has long been suspicious that county contracts for goods, services and construction were rigged.
"Some of the people I have worked with on Commissioner's Court are really stupid," said Haggerty, brother of longtime state Rep. Pat Haggerty, R-El Paso. "They thought they could do whatever they were doing that was totally corrupt, not knowing that it was totally corrupt.
"If this is OK, why are we meeting in this stall in the bathroom on the basement floor of the courthouse?" Haggerty said. "Why does it smell in here?"
Ketner's pleading described a courthouse restroom meeting between Cobos (described as "Co-conspirator Five") and Duran ("Co-conspirator Seven") involving a promise of money from Duran for contracts benefiting Duran's clients.The document charges that county contracts were selected based on "who offered ... the greatest amount of remuneration in money or other benefits."
Duran and Cobos have denied the allegations.
Placing blame
Duran served on the boundary commission until a scathing report by the State Department's inspector general two years ago forced his resignation. The report blamed Duran for creating internal management problems that engulfed the agency, "threatening its essential responsibilities for flood control and water management in the American Southwest."
After Ketner's plea became public, an indignant El Pasoan, Lisa Turner, showed up at the next commissioners court meeting to urge Cobos, Teran and Sarinana to resign.
Replying for the embattled three, Cobos blamed unnamed local power brokers for the legal storm.
"When you go against the status quo, you better be ready, because that's what I have done," Cobos said. "There are many people in this community with so much money and so much power. If I rubber-stamped what they wanted to do, this never would have happened."
Expanding investigation
After the FBI searched his office, Cobos told local reporters the agents could have simply requested documents and suggested the raid might be a "political blunt instrument to tarnish reputations."
He didn't appear any more rattled after his former chief of staff accused him.
Ketner's allegations did not trouble him, Cobos said, "because I know the truth. Obviously, they are encouraging him to get creative."
The FBI and the U.S. Attorney's Office have not commented except for terse news releases after the searches and after Ketner's guilty plea.
"We have been very tight-lipped about this investigation," acknowledged El Paso FBI spokeswoman Andrea Simmons. "It's an ongoing investigation, so it's not at a stage where we can give any details."
The probe initially focused on the alleged improper use of federal funds at a nonprofit called the National Center for Employment of the Disabled, since renamed ReadyOne. It has expanded to the county courthouse and is expected to reach El Paso school districts. The FBI also has requested documents from a prior City Hall administration, two current City Council members said.
Far-reaching probe
The FBI executed search warrants of 22 El Paso residences or businesses and wiretapped phones for nearly a year, an unusually long time, according to a former federal prosecutor.
"It tells me that the investigation is very far-reaching," said San Antonio lawyer Ron Ederer, a former U.S. attorney for the Western District of Texas under President George H.W. Bush. The probe is based on allegations of wrongdoing, not politics, Ederer said.
The investigation is "the subject of conversation everywhere," said longtime El Paso attorney Tom Diamond, who has served several terms as chairman of the El Paso Democratic Party.
"Out here, we're a little bit desensitized to the mordida (bribes). We have it right across the border. It's something that you don't consider because it's so prevalent in Mexico. I think it kind of bleeds over into our society," he said.
But that's changing, said Ederer, who practiced law in El Paso for 18 years before becoming a U.S. attorney.
"The city is no longer a little border town," he said. "It's growing by leaps and bounds and, as a result of that, law enforcement is becoming more sophisticated."
And industry expanding to border communities won't tolerate backroom deals, he said.
The probe, especially its gigantic scale, has angered some El Pasoans.
"We're shaking our heads. It's terrible. There is shock and outrage throughout the county," said Don Kirkpatrick, a Democratic Party activist. "What we have is a huge interlocking scandal, and at the center of it is Luther Jones."
'Cloud of gossip'
Jones, 60, served four terms in the Texas House in the 1970s. He later became El Paso county attorney and then county judge. For most of the past two decades, Jones has helped elect members to school boards, the City Council and county Commissioners Court, and he helped Ketner get his chief-of-staff job with Cobos.
Critics contend his influence has helped him secure contracts for friends.
"The city is just consumed in a cloud of gossip and rumors," Jones said in a recent interview. "My name is mentioned all the time, everything from being someone who's going to be dragged off in shackles to someone who's actively working behind the scenes with law enforcement people."
FBI agents searched Jones' home last fall.
Jones said he's not worried but acknowledges that "when lay people see your name in the papers associated with anything that has the word 'FBI' in front of it, automatically it conjures up notions that not only are you a criminal, but you're a seriously dangerous criminal."
Seeking a change
The allegations by Ketner "are all beneath contempt and unworthy of any response except categorical denial," Jones said.
The county commissioners whose offices were searched also deny any wrongdoing.
"I am not concerned. I never solicited nor have I ever accepted a bribe or money in exchange for any decision in the court," Teran said.
"I sleep comfortable at night," Sarinana said.
Whatever happens, some young El Paso political leaders are calling for a sea change in local politics.
"If good people are willing to step in and take leadership roles, then good things will happen," said Susie Byrd, a member of the El Paso City Council. "It won't happen on its own."
Read more
Saturday, June 23, 2007
State to pay schools' legal fees - DISD, others in funding lawsuit awarded $4.2 million
By TERRENCE STUTZ - The Dallas Morning News - Friday, June 22, 2007
AUSTIN – Dallas and hundreds of other school districts that successfully challenged Texas' school finance system scored a follow-up victory Thursday when an appeals court awarded them $4.2 million in legal fees.
The 3rd Texas Court of Appeals overruled objections by state attorneys and ordered the state to pay the school districts' attorney fees.
In a unanimous decision, the appellate court said its decision was based in part on the failure of the state to file a timely appeal after a state judge awarded fees to the school districts.
The lawsuit culminated in a decision by the Texas Supreme Court in November 2005 that ordered the Legislature to fix the state's unconstitutional property tax system to finance public schools.
Six months later in a special session, state lawmakers approved a school funding system that was less dependent on property taxes. The legislation reduced local school property taxes by a third and replaced the revenue with higher taxes on businesses and smokers.
While the school districts won on the property tax argument, they lost on another argument that the state was not providing adequate funding to educate their students. The high court ruled for the state on the latter issue, but did caution that current funding levels for schools are barely adequate.
Because it was a split decision, the attorney general's office later argued that the school districts were not entitled to recovery of legal fees in the case.
But the appellate court justices said state attorneys made their argument too late and should have raised the point when the case was originally appealed to the Supreme Court. Because of that failure, the state waived its right to contest a lower-court decision from state District Judge John Dietz awarding the fees, according to the ruling.
Dallas lawyer George Bramblett, who represented one group of school districts, said the $4.2 million award would go back to the school districts, which have already paid their lawyers. "It is a reasonable amount considering that it covers legal work done over six years," Mr. Bramblett said. "We clearly had a right to recover fees because we won the case."
A spokesman for the attorney general's office said no decision has been made on whether to appeal the decision to the Supreme Court.
Read more
AUSTIN – Dallas and hundreds of other school districts that successfully challenged Texas' school finance system scored a follow-up victory Thursday when an appeals court awarded them $4.2 million in legal fees.
The 3rd Texas Court of Appeals overruled objections by state attorneys and ordered the state to pay the school districts' attorney fees.
In a unanimous decision, the appellate court said its decision was based in part on the failure of the state to file a timely appeal after a state judge awarded fees to the school districts.
"We hold that the award of attorneys' fees to each of the school districts was equitable and just, in light of the fact that the districts were required to pursue extensive and costly litigation in order to remedy a school finance problem with statewide implications,"the three-judge panel said in its opinion.
"The record reflects that the districts made significant contributions in what turned out to be a highly complex lawsuit that required large amounts of statistical and demographic data."
The lawsuit culminated in a decision by the Texas Supreme Court in November 2005 that ordered the Legislature to fix the state's unconstitutional property tax system to finance public schools.
Six months later in a special session, state lawmakers approved a school funding system that was less dependent on property taxes. The legislation reduced local school property taxes by a third and replaced the revenue with higher taxes on businesses and smokers.
While the school districts won on the property tax argument, they lost on another argument that the state was not providing adequate funding to educate their students. The high court ruled for the state on the latter issue, but did caution that current funding levels for schools are barely adequate.
Because it was a split decision, the attorney general's office later argued that the school districts were not entitled to recovery of legal fees in the case.
But the appellate court justices said state attorneys made their argument too late and should have raised the point when the case was originally appealed to the Supreme Court. Because of that failure, the state waived its right to contest a lower-court decision from state District Judge John Dietz awarding the fees, according to the ruling.
Dallas lawyer George Bramblett, who represented one group of school districts, said the $4.2 million award would go back to the school districts, which have already paid their lawyers. "It is a reasonable amount considering that it covers legal work done over six years," Mr. Bramblett said. "We clearly had a right to recover fees because we won the case."
A spokesman for the attorney general's office said no decision has been made on whether to appeal the decision to the Supreme Court.
Read more
Tuesday, June 12, 2007
Williams possibly preparing run for office
Perry could tap current or former aides
to replace him as chief elections officer.
COMMENTARY:
by W. GARDNER SELBY - AMERICAN-STATESMAN STAFF -Tuesday, June 12, 2007
to replace him as chief elections officer.
by W. GARDNER SELBY - AMERICAN-STATESMAN STAFF -Tuesday, June 12, 2007
Secretary of State Roger Williams is stepping down as the state's chiefRead more
elections officer, most likely to prepare for running for statewide office.
Williams on Monday announced his resignation, effective July 1. He declined to detail his plans except to say, "I don't think I'm going to be a lobbyist."
He had nearly $194,000 in his office's political account as of Dec. 31 and hasn't cloaked his ambitions. He said recently that he'd be interested in a U.S. Senate bid if Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison of Texas tries for governor in 2010.
...
Gov. Rick Perry, who appointed Williams to the post in late 2004, said Williams "has been an incredible salesman for the State of Texas, and his leadership will be missed."
Williams, 57, a Weatherford car dealer and businessman, took office Feb. 8, 2005. Before that, he was a high-dollar fundraiser for President Bush's campaigns and a former major-league baseball prospect.
Perry's office said nothing Monday about possible successors. Names circulating at the Capitol include those of Phil Wilson, Perry's deputy chief of staff, and Brian Newby, Perry's general counsel. Other possibilities include lobbyists Robert Howden, a former senior adviser and communications director for Perry, and Luis Saenz, a former assistant secretary of state who directed Perry's 2006 re-election campaign.
Howden said: "If (Perry) asked me to come back, I would be all ears." Saenz had no comment.
...
The secretary of state oversees elections and doubles as liaison for the governor on border and Mexican affairs. The office also serves as the state's repository for official and business records, and it publishes government rules and regulations.
...
The office as a launch pad for politics "isn't the same as having your name on the ballot," Kirk recalled. "But it's better than starting from scratch."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Related Publications
The Arlington Texan, a portal to news and coverage of issues and events of and about Arlington, Texas.
DFW Regional Concerned Citizens is a sister-site of Grassroots News You Can Use. Visitors can subscribe to issues-specific and county specific action alerts using a simple form on the site.
About Air and Water focuses on DFW Regional air quality and water/gas drilling issues.
We welcome your feedback.